Best Ice Fishing Shanties and Shelters – 2021 Review

| Last Updated December 21, 2021

When buying or building an ice fishing shanty this winter, your number one priorities should be keeping warm with the right shelter and the proper outdoor clothing. However, your preeminent concern, before you even start to daydream about your ice fishing shanty and before you go shopping for well insulated outdoor clothing, should be safety.

Make sure that the lake you’re on has a sufficient cover of ice. Unless it’s your first season in a new area, you probably already know this, but every year some intrepid souls go out too early and risk injury or death.

Inside an ice fishing shanty, most anglers huddle in their outdoor clothing and install hand-lines and tip-ups (a device that sprouts a red flag when a fish bites). Be sure to dress warmly, because this is a very sedentary sport; you will spend a lot of time sitting around waiting for your fish to bite. Another important reminder: alcohol makes frostbite a real danger. Drink responsibly.

Comparison of the Best Ice Fishing Shanties

IMAGEPRODUCT
  • Best overall and best pop-up ice fishing shelter
  • Capacity: 3-4
  • Dimensions: 94 x 94 x 80"
View Latest Price →
  • Runner-up
  • Capacity: 2
  • Dimensions: 60 x 60 x 67"
View Latest Price →
  • Best for the money
  • Capacity: 2-3
  • Dimensions: 58 x 58 x 66"
View Latest Price →
  • Best 2 man ice fishing shelter
  • Capacity: 3-4
  • Dimensions: 90 x 90 x 80"
View Latest Price →
  • Best 3 person ice fishing shelter
  • Capacity: 3
  • Dimensions: 90 x 90 x 80"
View Latest Price →
  • Best Clam Ice Fishing Shelter
  • Capacity: 2
  • Dimensions: 92 x 61 x 69”
View Latest Price →

What is an Ice Fishing Shanty or Shelter, and What Are They Used For?

An ice shanty is referred to as a portable shelter that can be placed on a frozen lake while you are out on a fishing adventure. They fall in a variety of sizes ranging from small to large ones with greater capacity. Some of them are even incorporated with luxury facilities like heat, electricity, and cooking facilities to enhance your fishing experience.

These shelters have become a popular choice for their portable design. Most of them offer enough room for up to 3 people and keep them warm, safe, and ultimately productive by preventing cold air from getting in.

Ice Fishing Shanty or Just Warm Outdoor Clothing?

Many anglers find that they do not need or desire an ice fishing shanty. These fishermen think that warm, outdoor clothing will suffice to keep them safe from the elements. They may be right at times, depending on where they live. However, these structures serve as more than just shelter; they also serve as overhead protection from the sun’s glare as well as lateral protection from the glare off the ice. On a sunny day, even if it’s below freezing, sunburns are a real risk.

A good ice fishing shanty makes it easier for you to catch fish for two reasons. First, it allows you to bear the elements long enough to actually get some strikes. Second, it makes it easier for the fish to see the bait since it is in shadow. Outdoor clothing, no matter how high quality, cannot perform these tasks.

Key Terms to Know

To help compare products in this review, we have included a few key specifications for each. Here is a quick summary of what they mean.

  • Capacity: The number of people the shanty can accommodate.

  • Dimensions: The length, width, and height of the shanty.

  • Weight: Carrying weight of the shanty.

  • Type: The type of shanty. This can include fold-over, tent-style, as well as whether it has a built-in sled, or is meant to be towed.

  • Insulated? Whether the shanty has any type of insulating properties.

  • Materials: The materials of both the shanty and the support pieces that hold it up.

  • Fishable Area: The amount of space when assembled for fishing setup and seating. 

  • Comfort Features: These are additional features such as windows, seating, rod holders, ventilation, windows, etc for ease of use and comfort. 

Review of the Best Ice Fishing Shanties

Below are the best ice fishing shanties and shelters; take a close look and use your best judgement to select a product that will be ideally suited to fulfill your needs.

Best Overall and Best Pop-Up Ice Fishing Shelter:
Eskimo FF6120

Eskimo FF949 FatFish Pop-up Portable Hub-Style Ice Shelter, Wide Bottom Design 61 sq ft. Fishable Area, 3-4 Person Non-Insulated , Red , 99' x 99'

PROS

  • Easy setup and high portability
  • Provides significant warmth
  • Appealing, attractive design
  • Offers enough space to accommodate multiple people
  • Manufactured from high-quality fabric to mark durability

CONS

  • Somewhat bulky
  • More expensive than some alternatives
  • Does not include any floor

What Recent Buyers Report 

Users of this product are very contented with its performance. They report that the shelter is highly durable and capable of withstanding tough conditions easily. One of the most appreciated components is its large capacity, which can easily accommodate 3-4 persons at a time. While it is a bit expensive, it is certainly worth the price.

Why it Stands Out to Us 

This Eskimo ice fishing shelter resoundingly impressed us with its easy installation and durable, portable design. It is made from top-notch fabric that is sturdy enough to stand the test of time. It also features a metal ball and socket design that makes it strong and very comfortable. There are two doors and six windows to allow better viewing frames for you.

Who Will Use This Most 

Since it comes with a large capacity, this shelter is an ideal choice to accommodate 3-4 people at a time during your ice fishing adventure. It is extremely comfortable and provides great warmth in order to beat the cold conditions. Due to its hefty price tag, it is not suitable for those on a tight budget.

Bottom Line

An extraordinary product with a great set of features, this ice fishing shelter is built to last long, thanks to its tough fabric. Moreover, it is highly portable and installation is a breeze. With this shelter, you don’t have to worry about extreme weather conditions as it provides a suitable temperature to enhance your comfort level.

Product Specs

Capacity:

3-4

Dimensions:

94 x 94 x 80"

Weight:

44 lbs

Type:

Tent

Insulated?

Yes

Materials:

600 Denier insulated quilted fabric
All-metal ball-and-socket
Fiberglass poles

Fishable Area:

61 sq ft

Comfort Features:

Tie-downs & Ice anchor grommets
Detachable hook and loop window panels
Mesh storage pockets

Runner-up:
Eskimo Quickfish Portable Ice Fishing Shelter

Eskimo Quickfish 69151 2 Pop-up Portable Ice Shelter, 2 Person , Red

PROS

  • Installation takes less than a minute
  • Relatively lightweight and highly portable
  • Long-lasting fabric is great for long-term use
  • Suitable option for accommodating 2 people
  • Bright red colored design that goes with your personality

CONS

  • Poles could be improved
  • Difficult to store in a carrying bag
  • Door is a little low that causes inconvenience

What Recent Buyers Report 

Similar to our best overall choice, this runner-up ice shelter has also succeeded in winning the confidence of its users. According to them, this model comes with a durable construction that saves the user from the hassle of frequent repairing. Moreover, it is highly portable, and the installation does not require too much struggle.

Why it Stands Out to Us 

This ice shelter earns its position as the runner-up for featuring a durable design that tends to serve the user in the long run. It is made from 300 denier ice tight fabric and equipped with 6 self-tapping anchors to provide strength to the ice shelter. Moreover, the installation is very easy, and its high portability makes it exceedingly convenient.

Who Will Use This Most 

In case one of your friends is accompanying you on your fishing excursion, then this ice shelter is the perfect option. It can easily accommodate two adults at a time and yet provides enough space to fit your fishing accessories easily. It proves to be great at preventing the cold from getting in.

Bottom Line

One of the finest ice shelters on the market, this Eskimo shelter is well-known for its quality construction. Whether we talk about its installation or portability, this model won't disappoint you. Overall, it offers a warm setup to the user in order to guarantee a reliable experience.

Product Specs

Capacity:

2

Dimensions:

60 x 60 x 67"

Weight:

21.5 lbs

Type:

Tent

Insulated?

No

Materials:

300 Denier IceTight Fabric
All-Metal Hubs & Solid Poles

Fishable Area:

25 sq ft

Comfort Features:

Tie-downs & Ice anchor grommets
Mesh storage pockets
Removable Window Panels

Best for the Money:
Tangkula Pop-up Ice Shelter 2-Person

Tangkula Ice Fishing Shelter, Pop-up Portable Ice Shanty Tent for 2-3 Person, Waterproof Ice Shelter w/Carrier Bag, Detachable Ventilated Windows & Zippered Door for Ice Fishing, Black

PROS

  • Resists mildew growth from melted ice
  • Surely the most reasonably priced model on this list
  • Extremely lightweight and easy to carry around
  • Waterproof finish helps in avoiding any damage
  • Attractive design with highly durable construction

CONS

  • Can’t fit three people as advertised
  • Carry bag handle can't be held for a long time
  • Zipping and unzipping the door requires struggle

What Recent Buyers Report 

This superb product has received many positive reviews from customers due to its superior performance. The most attractive thing about it is its affordable price when compared to its competitors, particularly considering how resilient it is to adverse conditions. Moreover, you don't have to spend too much time on the installation of this ice shelter.

Why it Stands Out to Us 

This Tangkula ice fishing shelter stands out from its rivals due to its reasonable price tag. It is crafted of 300 Oxford tough fabric that can easily endure harsh weather conditions. Plus, it is completely waterproof and accommodates two people at a time. Moreover, the windows ensure a perfect view while keeping the cold wind outside.

Who Will Use This Most 

With great capacity, this model is advertised to fit 2-3 people. Bear in mind that some users have found three people to be excessive; however, two people can very comfortably fit inside. The high-quality fabric tends to provide warmth in cold conditions and resist air from getting inside. Moreover, it is lightweight and therefore can be easily carried around whenever you intend to go out fishing.

Bottom Line

Another great product on our list, this ice shelter from Tangkula is equipped with some exceptional features at a surprisingly affordable price. It is weather-resistant, waterproof, and quite durable. Keeping all these points in mind, honestly, it is an absolute steal.

Product Specs

Capacity:

2-3

Dimensions:

58 x 58 x 66"

Weight:

22 lbs

Type:

Tent

Insulated?

No

Materials:

300D Oxford fabric

Comfort Features:

Frost Resistance
Detachable windows
3D ventilation

Best One Person Ice Fishing Shelter: 
Eskimo QuickFlip 15300

Eskimo 15300 QuickFlip 1 Portable Flip Style Ice Fishing Shelter with 50' Sled & Tripod Chair, 1 Person

PROS

  • Easy to use whenever you want
  • Package includes a foldable chair
  • Offers a compact and impressive design
  • Detachable windows to add on to perfection
  • Manufactured from ice tight fabric to enhance the durability

CONS

  • Installation can be tricky
  • Rattles a lot in windy conditions
  • Can’t accommodate multiple fishing accessories

What Recent Buyers Report 

This ice shelter has gained many positive remarks from its customers. One of the most admired things is its exquisite design, which is built to serve the user in the long run and keep the user nice and warm. Moreover, the portable design saves the user from any hassle.

Why it Stands Out to Us 

If you are looking for a great solo ice shelter, then you must get your hands on this product. It is crafted of 300 Denier ice tight fabric and weighs only 52 pounds. Its lightweight design enhances its portability, and the double-walled hinge adds on to the strength of the shelter. 

Who Will Use This Most 

Ideally designed for one person, this is the best option you will find on the market in terms of quality and price. It is effective in withstanding harsh conditions and keeps the temperature inside warm by keeping the cold wind outside. Moreover, it can be carried around easily thanks to its user-friendly design.

Bottom Line

A powerhouse of features, this solo ice shelter is destined to serve you for a long time. Made from quality materials and featuring an appealing design, this can easily fit one person in extreme weather conditions. Plus, the package includes a foldable chair to add on to perfection.

Product Specs

Capacity:

1

Dimensions:

50 x 32 x 10"

Weight:

52 lbs

Type:

Sled mounted

Insulated?

No

Materials:

IceTight fabric
Round Aluminum

Fishable Area:

9.3 sq ft

Comfort Features:

Folding Ice Chair

Best Two Person Ice Fishing Shelter:
Goplus Portable Ice Shelter

Goplus 2-4 People Ice Fishing Shelter, Pop-up Portable Ice Fishing Tent with Carrying Bag, Windows, Zippered Door, Ground Nail and Wind Rope, Insulated Ice Shanty House for Winter Fishing, Red

PROS

  • Equipped with an additional PVC layer
  • Portable design is easy to carry around
  • Suitable to endure -30°F frost conditions
  • Sturdy design with water-resistant capability
  • Manufactured from heavy-duty fabric to enhance the durability

CONS

  • Windows are small
  • PVC is not of good quality
  • Can’t fit three people as advertised

What Recent Buyers Report 

Users of this product have found this to be suitable for two people, not the advertised three. However, they were quite impressed with its ability to resist cold wind, even at -30°F. The waterproof design avoids any damage to the shelter, and users have found it to be highly portable. This product can easily endure harsh weather conditions like a pro.

Why it Stands Out to Us 

This ice shelter from Goplus is manufactured from 300D ice tight fabric, which is additionally complemented by a PVC layer to enhance the durability of the product. The whole design is completely waterproof and includes 6 anchors that increase its strength. Moreover, the installation does not require any struggle, and a carrying bag easily fits this shelter for improved portability.

Who Will Use This Most 

One of the most user-friendly models on our list, this ice shelter is proved to be a suitable choice for two people. You can easily go with a friend for a fishing adventure whenever you want without getting worried about the weather conditions. Since the design is waterproof, there is practically no risk of frequent replacements.

Bottom Line

If you are looking for a shelter to accompany you on a fishing trip, then you should consider this model from Goplus. Not only is it made from high-quality materials, but it is also effective in providing superior performance. With this shelter, you can simply ace your fishing experience.

Product Specs

Capacity:

3-4

Dimensions:

90 x 90 x 80"

Weight:

22.4 lbs

Type:

Tent

Insulated?

No

Materials:

300D Oxford fabric & PVC
Fibre pole

Comfort Features:

Waterproof
-30℉ Frost Resistance
Detachable windows

Best Three Person Ice Fishing Shelter:
 THUNDERBAY Ice Cube 3 Man

THUNDERBAY Ice Cube 3-4 Man Portable Ice Shelter, 34 Square Feet of Fishable Area, Portable 3-4 Person Ice Shanty

PROS

  • Comes at a relatively good price
  • Strong fabric to avoid any damage
  • Includes a carry bag to enhance transportation
  • Offers an exquisite design that blocks cold air
  • Equipped with a blackout coating to keep the light away

CONS

  • Blackout light filter is subpar
  • Extra door should be included
  • Ventilation control could be improved

What Recent Buyers Report 

This model has gained great ratings from customers for its unmatched performance. Its most appreciated qualities are its high-quality construction and enormous capacity. Users report that they don't find any difficulties in its portability, thanks to the user-friendly carry bag. Plus, the anchors are great in improving strength.

Why it Stands Out to Us 

This Ice Cube fishing shelter is well-known for its attractive design. It is manufactured from heavy-duty yet lightweight fabric to provide reliable durability. It features a blackout filter to keep the light away. Best of all, its insulation control is optimal for maintaining a warm temperature.

Who Will Use This Most 

Suitable for three people, this shelter comes with insulation and ventilation control to enhance the experience of the user. Not only can it can easily fit three people, there is even room for additional fishing accessories. Plus, the design is waterproof to avoid any damage and repair expenditures. What else could you ask for?

Bottom Line

Overall, this shelter is great for keeping the cold air from getting in. It is highly versatile and easily accommodates three people at a time without any hassle. Plus, the price is really affordable when compared to other comparable alternatives. In short, you won’t find a better option on the market.

Product Specs

Capacity:

3

Dimensions:

90 x 90 x 80"

Weight:

26.25 lbs

Type:

Tent

Insulated?

No

Materials:

300 denier fabric
Fibreglass poles

Fishable Area:

34 sq ft

Comfort Features:

Blackout coating
Hook and loop fastened windows

Best Ice Fishing Flip Over Shelter:
Frabill Recon 100

Frabill Recon 100 Flip-Over Shelter with Pad Trunk Seat 5000708

PROS

  • Moderate price range
  • Lightweight design allows easy mobility
  • Durable material prevents tears and rips
  • Padded trunk of the shanty acts as a comfortable seating area
  • For entering, there is no door, but a simple flip-over action allows you in

CONS

  • Only suited for a single person
  • Due to the lightweight material used in the body, it fails to provide abundant insulation

What Recent Buyers Report 

Users praise the tent’s lightweight design. Most people love that it is easy to fit into any vehicle and is super easy to carry around. The tent is snug and warm and provides a good barrier against the cold to a solo fisherman.

Why it Stands Out to Us 

Not only is it easy to get in and out, but the tent is also super affordable and durable. It is not a burden on the pocket and is perfectly suited for a single individual. Frabill Recon 100 is a great buy for an average fisher who does not spend numerous days fishing in the open. 

It is also easy to travel with and can be moved about to change positions for a better catch. This is also a great feature since one person cannot be expected to carry around too much weight for average insulation.

Bottom Line

All in all, the Frabill Recon 100 is great for anyone who fishes for recreation. It is perfect for people that are looking for a durable, small fishing tent that keeps them warm throughout the excursion.

Product Specs

Capacity:

1

Dimensions:

93 x 31 x 57"

Weight:

40 lbs

Type:

Sled mounted

Insulated?

No

Materials:

300D Fabric

Fishable Area:

8.5 sq ft

Comfort Features:

Folding chair
Removable clear window
Padded seat

Best Clam Ice Fishing Shelter:
Clam Corporation 112847

CLAM Corporation 112847 Nanook XL Thermal - 2 Anglers

PROS

  • Can easily accommodate two people
  • Deeper tub allows more fishing space
  • Lightweight design allows ease in portability
  • Has more storage space to store fishing tools and other items
  • 900 denier fabric used in tent construction provides excellent insulation

CONS

  • A bit on the expensive side in terms of pricing
  • Seat covers are sold separately, and the seats are slightly too low

What Recent Buyers Report 

The Clam 112847 Nanook XL provides excellent insulation due to its 900-denier fabric as claimed by buyers. Users also report that it has more space and allows you to enjoy a greater fishing area. The tent is also perfect for two friends or a couple on a fishing excursion.

Why it Stands Out to Us 

Although not the cheapest, the tent provides excellent insulation and keeps the inside area warm and cozy. The pole system and new tub increase not only fishing space but storage area as well. The chairs are removable, but seat covers have to be purchased separately.

Once you remove the chairs, the tent is pretty lightweight and can be easily carried in a truck. It is also easy to set up and install and rules out hassle each time you choose a spot to set it up.

Bottom Line

To sum up, the tent easily accommodates two people and provides excellent insulation. It is lightweight and portable. It is also a breeze to install, which makes it even more likable.

Product Specs

Capacity:

2

Dimensions:

92 x 61 x 69”

Weight:

76 lbs

Type:

Sled mounted

Insulated?

Yes

Materials:

900-denier fabric

Fishable Area:

23 sq ft

Comfort Features:

Removable chairs
Overhead mesh storage

Best Four Person Ice Fishing Shelter and Best Six Person Ice Fishing Shelter: 
Elkton Outdoors Portable 3-8 Person Ice Fishing Tent

Elkton Outdoors Portable 3-4 Person Ice Fishing Tent with Ventilation Windows and Carry Pack, Ice Fishing Shelter Includes Tent, Carry Pack, Ice Anchors and Storage Compartments

PROS

  • Installation does not take much time
  • Great at keeping the temperature warm
  • Carrying bag comes with a wide opening
  • Very attractive design
  • Equipped with three thermal insulation layers

CONS

  • Windows are at a height
  • Larger groups might feel somewhat cramped
  • Quite a bulky model when packed away

What Recent Buyers Report 

This product has satisfied many users with its reliable construction and top-notch performance. Its most beloved feature is its huge capacity that can easily accommodate four or more people. Moreover, it comes with many storage pockets that serve ample space for your fishing accessories. Similarly, you can pack this shelter in a carrying bag, and it’s good to go.

Why it Stands Out to Us 

The Elkton shelter is one of the most reliable ice fishing shelters you'll find on the market. It is built from heavy-duty fabric and includes three insulation layers to keep the stuff warm. There are additional storage pockets on the sides of the shelter, plus four ventilation pockets on the top of the tent.

Who Will Use This Most 

If you love to go fishing with large groups of friends, then this is just the right option for you. It is capable of accommodating over four persons without any hassle and offers additional space for your accessories as well. Plus, strong insulation control provides a warm temperature, making it an ideal choice in cold conditions.

Bottom Line

Like our above-mentioned option, this ice shelter is no less in its quality performance. Made from high-end fabric and with a waterproof design, it is meant to serve you for a long time. In a nutshell, it won’t do you wrong in tough weather conditions, thanks to its three layers of insulation.

Product Specs

Capacity:

3-4

Dimensions:

70 x 70 x 80"

Type:

Tent

Insulated?

No

Materials:

300D oxford polyester

Fishable Area:

34 sq ft

Comfort Features:

4 ventilation pockets
3 layers insulation

Best Insulated Ice Fishing Shelter:
Eskimo FatFish 949i Series

Eskimo FatFish Series Pop-Up Portable Ice Fishing Shelter

PROS

  • Six self-tapping anchors hook easily onto the ice
  • Can be easily stored in a large duffle bag, which aids portability
  • Perfect for a group as it can easily accommodate up to 4 people
  • Sturdy and durable due to its fiberglass poles plus metal and socket ball construction
  • Insulated quilted material used to create the body provides 35% more insulation as compared to an ordinary tent

CONS

  • Slightly costlier compared to other tents
  • Not waterproof at all and leaks during rain

What Recent Buyers Report 

Clients have commended the Eskimo FatFish 949i series. Most people are impressed with its adequate room for three to four people and love that it's super cozy and warm. The tent is also super sturdy and durable.

Why it Stands Out to Us 

Sturdy construction, perfect insulation, and room for three to four people; what more could you ask for? But, the Eskimo FatFish 949i has tons more to offer. Not only is it super easy to set up and install, but it also stays in place and is able to provide the warmth a small family would require whilst living in the tent.

Moreover, the shanty is easy to move about. Although not super-light, it still is mobile enough for three to four people to carry easily. Removable window panels and self-tapping anchors that latch onto ice are further features that you simply cannot ignore. 

As if all this was not enough, the product also offers mesh pockets for easy storage, deluxe ties, high-quality zippers, and robust corner joints.

Bottom Line

Conclusively, the Eskimo FatFish 949i is perfect for a small family or a group of friends consisting of up to four people. It can easily accommodate three large adults and keep them warm perfectly. Easy mobility, sturdy construction, and smooth installation are also features that make this tent a good pick.

Product Specs

Capacity:

3-4

Dimensions:

94 x 94 x 80"

Weight:

44 lbs

Type:

Tent

Insulated?

Yes

Materials:

600 Denier insulated quilted fabric
All-metal ball-and-socket
Fiberglass poles

Fishable Area:

61 sq ft

Comfort Features:

Tie-downs & Ice anchor grommets
Detachable hook and loop window panels
Mesh storage pockets

Is a Shanty Necessary When Ice Fishing?

You may be wondering whether you actually need a shanty whilst ice fishing. This is an obvious question that may come to mind once you decide to go ice fishing.

In short, yes, a shanty or shelter is necessary whilst ice fishing to protect you from the cold. However, a portable unit such as the ones mentioned above is an absolute gift to yourself. Below are some benefits you'll get by having one added to your ice fishing gear. 

Mobility and Portability

Compared to wooden tents or other similar shelters, a fishing tent is great as it allows you to easily change positions and choose a new fishing spot. Portable tents are perfect for those who may plan to fish alone and cannot really carry around extra weight.

Insulation

Denier fabric used in the construction of most shanties provides excellent insulation. This not only keeps you super warm and cozy but also allows you to run a small heater inside the tent for maximum warmth.

Easy Fishing

Each tent either provides you a suitable hole or comes with no floor attached. This allows you to fish on ice easily without having to face the harsh weather.

Some even come with their own seats, which makes the experience even more comfortable.

Eskimo FF6120

What Size of Ice Fishing Shanty Do I Need?

Once you decide that you are actually going to invest in a fishing tent, the next thing you need to do is decide how large or small it should be.

If you like fishing alone, you can go for a small, one-person shanty. If you want to go fishing as a couple, then obviously you will require something larger. For a family, you will need to buy a tent according to the number of people.

You also need to consider whether they are all adults or whether they include children. Furthermore, it is also best to consider the height and build of each individual. You can then compare these with tent dimensions before making a purchase.

Types of Ice Fishing Shanties and Shelters

There is not one but four different types of ice fishing shelters or shanties used most commonly. Here’s a rundown of each to help you understand which one you actually need.

Hub 

Just as the name suggests, a hub shelter is super compact and portable. The design allows you to easily sit and fish, but it is not meant for standing positions. There is also no roaming space. 

However, the limited space makes the tent cozier than many others and is perfect for freezing temperatures.

Cabins

These are taller than hubs and allow a person to stand up inside them easily. The taller length of the tent makes it slightly less portable as compared to hubs.

Tangkula Pop-up Ice Shelter 2-Person

Windbreaks

Windbreak tents, as the name suggests, offer resistance against the harsh, chilly wind. They do not provide the insulation or warmth that most other tents do. However, they are perfect for dry, windy weather and provide an average barrier against weather conditions.

Flip-Style

A flip-style tent is the most portable option available in the market. Easy flip-over aids fishing and helps you move in and out with more ease.

Comparison Overview

In this section, we are going to compare and contrast the different variations in shanties to help you deduce which one is best for you.

Ice Fishing Shelter Insulated vs Uninsulated

An insulated ice fishing shelter made with tough, durable denier fabric is what you are going to need if you choose to fish in extreme cold. The insulation will not only keep you warm but will also allow you to run a heater inside, making it even warmer and cozier. It is perfect for below-zero temperatures. Also, if you are taking kids along, you will definitely require an insulated tent to keep them cozy.

An uninsulated tent or shelter is great for dry, windy weather or regions where it does not get too cold. They are definitely not suitable for ice fishing unless you plan to carry and wear a dozen jackets and sweaters. An uninsulated tent serves little purpose in chilly weather conditions.

Hub Shelters vs Flip Over for Ice Fishing

Hub shelters are great if you are a solo fisher. It is also great for protecting you against the cold weather. However, it allows no standing space, and you basically have to crawl in and out of the tent. It is super portable and light, which makes it a breeze to carry around.

Meanwhile, a flip-over tent is larger and allows you to enjoy standing and roaming space, given its size. The insulated fabric, along with a small heater, provides you the warmth you require. You can easily come in and out of the tent. Extra storage space and windows make it even more likable. A flip-over tent is also sturdier, robust, and more durable.

Clam vs Eskimo Ice Shelters

An Eskimo ice shelter can accommodate up to four people, whilst the Clam tent is only suited for a group of two. However, the latter provides greater storage and fishing area as compared to the former.

In terms of budget, the Eskimo shelter is slightly less costly compared to the Clam. Both provide adequate insulation and are fairly portable. The Clam comes with its own seats whilst the Eskimo does not. Seat covers for the former need to be purchased separately.

Aspects to Consider Before Buying

In case you have intended to purchase an ice fishing shanty, you are advised to take a few factors into consideration first in order to avoid any regret in the future. These factors will not only simplify your search but also help you purchase the best product available on the market. In this section, we have summarized a few crucial factors. Let's discuss them one by one:

Size

One of the most significant factors is the size or capacity of an ice fishing shanty. The choice generally depends on your requirements; however, it is always recommended to go for a model with extra-large space in order to perfectly fit your fishing equipment as well.

Weight

The weight of the shanty directly affects its portability. Therefore, you must opt for one with a reasonable weight that is easy to carry around while also adding to your comfort level.

Material

Ice shelters are manufactured from a variety of materials; however, the most commonly used ones are nylon, poly-cotton, and canvas. 

Goplus Portable Ice Shelter

Although all of them feature their own pros, you are advised to pick the fabric with the maximum durability and resistance to water and harsh elements.

Seating

There are many ice shelters that come with a built-in chair that provides enough comfort and support. However, it totally depends on the user's choice, whether they prefer to bring their own chair or opt for a built-in chair.

Cautious Considerations to Keep in Mind

That was all about the major factors that must be kept in mind while making a purchase. However, there are some cautious points that you should be aware of before you select a ice fishing shanty for yourself in order to have the best experience possible.

Brand

Since these shelters are going to be used in extreme weather conditions, the quality of the product is everything. The brand of the model dictates a lot about the quality and its capability to endure harsh weather conditions. You are recommended to go for a reputed brand with a proven track record in order to get the best bang for your buck.

Price

Ice fishing shelters fall in a wide range of prices and can be extremely costly. You’ll definitely find plenty of luxury options on the market. It is advised to not compromise on the quality while finding an option best fitted to your budget.

Set-up Time

Of course, you don't want to spend a great deal of your time setting up the shelter. There are various options available on the market, and it is suggested to go for a shanty that is highly portable and consumes less time, such as a folding tent that is easy to handle and fast to set up.

How to Assemble and Set Up an Ice Fishing Tent

You have purchased an ice fishing tent; what’s next? You obviously need to take it to your desired fishing location and set it up, right? And how exactly are you supposed to do that? We have put together steps you will need to follow to set up your ice fishing tent perfectly. Have a look:

  1. Once you pick a good fishing spot, the first thing you need to do is unpack your tent. Take it out of its storage bag and remove any cords or ties holding it together.

  2. Gently unpack it with your hands and find the middle or top of the tent. Use the top or center to tug and pull the tent into its shape.

  3. Once you’ve tugged and propped up the center, the next step is to pull out and shape the sides. Keep tugging and pulling until you see your tent taking its shape.

  4. Now, use ties, ice latches, and whatever else your tent comes with to prop it up perfectly in place. Make sure you latch every side, so it stays sturdy and in place.

  5. You can now place seats, mats, or whatever else you prefer inside the tent.

  6. Roll open windows if you need sunlight and set up a heater for warmth and insulation against the cold.

The above-mentioned steps are almost suitable for the Eskimo tent for three to four people. For a graphic representation of these steps, make sure to check out the following video: 

How to Pack Fishing Items in an Ice Shelter

Once you arrive at your location and set up your tent, how can you set up the inside perfectly for ice fishing? Let us look at what you can do to create an amazing setup:

  1. Place your buckets and sleds inside the tent if there is enough room or place them near your opening or door

  2. Next, place your fishing rods and lures in one corner where they are easy to grasp and are reachable

  3. Use a fish detector and ice auger to drill suitable holes in the ice floor

  4. Place your seat accordingly and position fishing rods and lines over the drilled holes

  5. Set up the heat and adjust the windows and openings for insulation

  6. All other eatables, accessories, and items can be placed neatly in a bag in the corner so you can reach out to them whenever the need arises

Still confused? Check out the following video to better understand how the inside of a tent should be managed and organized.

People Also Ask

Still have something on your mind? Are there questions that you feel may have still been left unanswered? This section is just for you. This section looks at some of the most common or frequently asked questions by users. 

What Do You Use For the Floor of Ice Fishing Shelter?

Considering the tent you have bought comes with no floor or seats, what can you use as flooring for your ice shanty? 

The flooring has to be insulating, so plywood or foam is not a bad option. Plywood, however, may be difficult to carry, and drilling new holes can get difficult. Foam is slightly better since it’s more portable, and new holes can be made much more easily. 

Another option is to use rubber mats or styrofoam. These are portable, drilling holes is easy, and they can provide sufficient insulation.

What Length Ice Rod is Best For Shanty Fishing?

Anything between 24 and 36 inches is a good length for an ice rod that is to be used inside a shanty. In general, it is best to use a medium or shorter rod compared to longer ones as shanties have less vertical space. 

Therefore, a medium-sized rod will not hinder movement, and it will be easier for you to set up your hook and lure.

Why Are Ice Fishing Shelters Black on the Inside?

The interior of some tents is generally coated with black chemicals or fabric to enable better sight fishing. Also known as spearfishing, the blackened inside minimizes the amount of light that falls into the tent. 

The black coating also increases insulation by retaining the heat. This also reduces the burden on your heater and allows you to stay warm and cozy.

Which is Better, Portable or Permanent Ice Fishing Houses?

Portable shanties, shelters, or fishing houses are certainly the latest thing in the market these days. A portable tent is definitely better and has more advantages. 

Eskimo Quickfish Portable Ice Fishing Shelter

Not only can it be moved about, but it can also be easily set up on almost any desirable fishing spot as compared to a permanent fishing house. The denier fabric of portable tents provides abundant insulation and completely rules out the need for permanent fish houses. Plus, the former is certainly much cheaper as compared to the latter.

How Much Should an Ice Fishing House Weigh?

The weight of an ice fishing house is what helps you decide the thickness of the ice you should fish on. An ideal 2200-pound shanty should essentially be placed on 18 inches of ice or more. 

With a heavier fishing tent, it is necessary you fish on thicker ice to avoid any safety threats. The heavier the tent, the thicker the ice should be the ice you fish on. 

It is also important to consider the tent’s weight if you do not want your tent hindering your mobility. A lightweight unit is best for fishing and is also super easy to carry around.

How Many People Can Fit in an Ice Fishing Shelter?

This depends on how tall and wide your shanty is. Before making your purchase, it is best to compare the dimensions with the size and space of individuals that are going to reside inside the tent. 

Furthermore, you must understand that different tents are suited for various purposes. You can easily choose between a single-person tent, one that is meant for two or buy one that can accommodate your family. 

Go for a regular family tent if your family consists of three to four people. Buy a larger one if you have a bigger family. A general hub or cabin will, however, only accommodate a single fisher.

                                   Share to Pinterest



My name is Caleb and I am obsessed with hunting, fishing, and foraging. To be successful, you have to think like your prey. You have to get into the mind of your target - and understand Big Game Logic. If you have any questions, or just want chat about your latest hunting score or big catch, you can reach me at admin@biggamelogic.com. Read more about Big Game Logic.