Best Fixed Blade Broadheads – 2019 Complete Review

Big Game Logic is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

Going hunting requires a few pieces of must-have gear. These include arrows and crossbows, of course, but another important tool has to be a razor sharp, fixed blade broadhead. This particular item has been used by hunters for centuries for the purpose of killing their prey and feeding themselves. 


With modern technology and engineering, primitive arrowheads have been transformed into fixed blade broadheads that do the same job but more effectively and with far more precision.

Comparison Chart of the Best Fixed Blade Broadheads

PRODUCT
gm2-table__image

Drone Broadhead by Wasp Archery

  • Solid steel body for strength and accuracy
  • 100-grain weight and 0.027” stainless steel blade for a clean cut
  • Made by Wasp Archery, this is the best overall fixed blade broadhead
View Latest Price
gm2-table__image

Muzzy Bowhunting Broadheads 3 Blades Trocar Tip

  • Available in 3 grains, i.e., 75, 100 and, 125.
  • Runner up of the best fixed blade broadheads available
  • 3 blade Trocar tip made out of steel with 0.020” razor-sharp blade
View Latest Price
gm2-table__image

Huntingdoor 12Pack 3 Fixed Blade Archery Broadheads

  • Best for the money
  • Stainless steel, 125-grain blade.
  • 3-blade design for a quick, smooth cut.
View Latest Price
gm2-table__image

Muzzy Trocar 100 Grain 3-Blade Broadhead

  • Compatible with compound bows and crossbows.
  • Strong, accurate hit even through the stoutest of animals.
  • 3-blade, 100-grain broadhead with a Trocar tip for an immediate cut.
View Latest Price
gm2-table__image

Carbon Express XT Dual Blade Serrated Crossbow Broadhead

  • The heads have 6 cutting edges.
  • Best 100-grain option, suitable for larger animals
  • 100-grain broadhead with 0.058” thick, stainless steel blades that make a 1 1/8” cutting diameter
View Latest Price
gm2-table__image

Muzzy Bowhunting Phantom Broadheads with Bleeder Blade

  • It has a secondary bleeder blade.
  • Best 125-grain option that features 4 sharp blades on the broadhead.
  • Comes in 100 and 125 grain weighs that gives a 1-1/8” wide cutting diameter.
View Latest Price

Fixed Blade Broadheads vs. Regular - What’s the Difference?

There are two types of broadheads available today – fixed blade broadheads and old-school, mechanical broadheads. Although used for the same purpose, the two have a number of differences. Both of them have pros and cons that make archers prefer either of the two for their hunting session.

Strength

Due to the blade not moving in fixed blade broadheads, they are much stronger than mechanical broadheads that have a deployable blade.

Price

Fixed blades are quite economical as compared to their mechanical counterparts that are likely to be more expensive.

Reliability

Again, with the fixed blade broadheads, the archer does not have to worry about the blade deploying upon impact because it is fixed in its place. However, for mechanical broadheads, there is potential for failure, such as premature deployment even before they come in contact with the target. Due to this, mechanical broadheads are much suitable for thin-skinned animals rather than thick-skinned.

Maintenance

Fixed blade broadheads can easily be sharpened to have a more effective kill while the mechanical broadhead is not so easy to maintain. It is difficult to upkeep as the blades need to be replaced. This not only adds up to their cost but is also time-consuming as the replacement needs to be done with screwdrivers.

What Size of Fixed Blade Broadheads Do I Need?

The weight and cutting diameter are the two most important aspects.

Fixed blade broadheads have variable weights expressed in grains. One may use a 75-grain option for an animal the size of a turkey, but for a heavier animal such as an elk or a bear, a heavier broadhead is needed.

Secondly, the larger the cutting diameter, the faster the blood loss, allowing you to take down an animal more efficiently. Generally, any diameter over an inch is sufficient for many game animals. Most manufacturers focus on information of such aspects so that the customer knows what to expect out of the fixed blade broadhead they’re choosing.

Characteristics of our Favorite Models

Finding the right broadhead is an essential step for successful hunting. Therefore, it is good to be mindful of a few critical aspects while buying one. Mentioned below are some of the most important factors.

Penetration Ability

It is of extreme importance that the broadhead guarantees the kill by piercing through the animal’s skin and reaching the internal organs. This not only reduces distress for the archer but also avoids unnecessary animal suffering and makes the kill as humane as possible.

Material and Quality

Fixed blade broadheads may be made of a single or combination of materials; however, it is important that the blade is of stainless steel. This is because stainless steel offers superior cutting power and can be honed to be razor sharp.

Drone Broadhead by Wasp Archery

Number of Blades

Manufacturers have been adding multiple blades to broadheads as a way of improving the overall hunting experience. However, many blades are of no use, and usually, 2-3 blades are more than enough. Often, the more blades there are, the weaker and thinner each individual blade will be. Therefore, if you want these to last a couple of seasons, then opt for fewer but thick and strong blades.

The Sharpness of the Blades

This is quite self-explanatory when it comes to hunting. The sharper the blade, the easier the kill. However, it is important to consider the procedure of sharpening the blade and its integrity before making a purchase.

Quick Take | Best Fixed Blade Broadheads

Review of the Best Fixed Blade Broadheads

Now that you know the key features to look for, let’s have a look at the best fixed blade broadheads we have selected from the many available; we’ve listed their features, pros, and cons so you can make a fully informed choice.

Wasp Drone Broadhead Archery

PROS

  • Guarantees precise penetration with its 0.027” blade
  • Made of steel to ensure a kill

CONS

  • Blades might break if the target is too sturdy or thick-skinned, such as an elk shoulder.

This is a 100 grain, solid steel broadhead that guarantees accuracy, penetration, and strength with its reduced ferrule surface area. Its razor sharp, stainless steel blade can blast through bone while being 0.027” to provide precision. The tip is pressed hard to omit any kind of movement and provide a clean puncture through any kind of surface it comes in contact with.

The Wasp Archery broadhead ensures a flawless, aerodynamic design for smooth cutting and flying. There are 3 heads per pack.

Bottom Line

This is a great product that truly serves its purpose. It is accurate in its aim and roars through the target, creating a straight cut path.

Muzzy Bowhunting Broadheads 3 Blades Trocar Tip, 75, 100 or 125 Grain, 6 Pack

PROS

  • Available in 3 different weights of about 75, 100, and 125 grain
  • 3-blade Trocar tip, which is made out of pure 100% steel
  • 75-grain head provides a 1” wide cut while the 100 and 125 grain give a gaping 1-3/16” cutting diameter
  • Manufactured from hardened steel to allow for better flight trajectory, accuracy and penetration into the animal

CONS

  • Blades seem to be slightly too long for the tip to be properly screwed onto it, which can affect performance

This broadhead carries a 3-blade Trocar tip that is made of hardened steel to maximize penetration into the target and enhance flight stability of the item itself. It is available in 75, 100, and 125 grain with the 100 and 125 grain having a 1-3/16” cutting diameter while the 75 grain provides a fairly 1” diameter.

The blade itself is about 0.020”, razor sharp, and firmly locks with the body. There are about 6 pieces per pack, being extremely economical for the users.

Bottom Line

Despite the one minor issue of it being too long, the Muzzy Bowhunting Broadhead flies consistently and provides an accurate, sharp kill as soon as it hits the target.

Huntingdoor 12Pack 3 Fixed Blade Archery Broadheads 125 Grain Arrow Head Hunting Arrow Tips Golden for Compound Bow and Crossbow

PROS

  • Also works well with bow arrows and crossbow belts
  • 3-blade design that allows a smooth, quick kill of the target
  • Sharp, fast, and affordable
  • Stainless steel, 125-grain blades ensure that the product is strong and durable for hunting and shooting

CONS

  • User might experience an arrow drift that is caused due to the large surface area of the blades
  • Users have complained of the product being cheaply made due to the blades breaking off and being difficult to screw back on

Huntingdoor broadheads are a heavy-duty 3-blade design, making them extremely sharp and accurate. They weigh about 125 grains and are 2.8 inches in length. The blades are made using durable stainless steel that can take down any kind of prey without any issue.

These heads are compatible with bow arrows and crossbow belts, making them a perfect piece for outdoor hunting as well as target practice.

Bottom Line

The Huntingdoor Broadhead is an extremely economical choice for those on a budget. Although it may not be great for big games, it works well for practice target shooting, basic hunting, or even small game hunting.

Muzzy Trocar 100 Grain 3-Blade Broadhead - 3 Pack

PROS

  • 3-blade broadhead for a clean cut
  • Promises a kill upon impact
  • Trocar tip on this head enhances penetration into the animal
  • Strong enough to pierce through bigger targets such as elk, deer, etc.
  • Can also be used with compound bows as well as crossbows

CONS

  • Broadhead itself is slightly smaller in size, and therefore the blades are looser on the heads
  • Does not provide a good blood trail, which is often an important consideration in hunting game

This 3-blade broadhead is full of strength and guarantees a 100% accurate shot each time. The tip of the blade of stays put, avoiding any kind of movement and disrupting the shot. This is a 100-grain broadhead that carries a Trocar tip for flawless hit and instant kill.

This is a heavy hitter head that can pass clean through any hog, deer, or elk with zero problems and come out the other side after complete bone destruction. These heads also work well with crossbows and compound bows, and there are 3 pairs of heads in each packet.

Bottom Line

In terms of strength, these are one of the best out there for larger, stronger animals. These heads do have loose blades, but they can be tightened easily to make them perfectly good for use.

Carbon Express XT Dual Blade Serrated Crossbow Broadhead, 100 Grain Weight, 3-Pack

PROS

  • Weighs about 100 grains
  • Long-lasting blades that do not require frequent sharpening
  • Enhanced precision and provides greater damage
  • Stainless steel 0.058” thick blades that cause a gaping 1 1/8” cutting diameter upon impact

CONS

  • Not suitable for long-range points and might not give the desired result

These heads fulfill their purpose of shooting accurately while delivering maximum damage to the target. These heads, unlike the regular heads, have six cutting edges. This feature causes an open wound that is about 250 times greater than other, traditional models. Their incredible aerodynamic profile and 100% spin provide improved precision and greater destruction upon hit.

This is a 100-grain broadhead by Carbon Express. Also, the blades are made of stainless steel with an aircraft grade aluminum ferrule, all of which together give an impressive 1 1/8” cutting diameter. These serrated 0.058” thick blade are also long-lasting and stay sharp for a long time.

The 6 cutting edge design on this provides immense destruction to the target, providing an instant kill and good cutting wound that is 250 times greater than the one created by traditional 3-blade broadheads.

Bottom Line

This 100-grain broadhead alone is enough to cause a lot of damage to the target, creating a good blood trail with its smooth, deep cuts. The 6 cutting edge design is perfect for smaller as well as bigger animals.

Muzzy 4125 Bowhunting Phantom 4 Blade 125 Grain, Broadhead, 1-1/8' Cutting Diameter, 3 pack

PROS

  • 4 very sharp blades for ultimate penetration.
  • 3 heads in each packet, making it quite economical.
  • Secondary bleeder blade is 0.028” thick
  • Available in both 100 and 125 grain with a 0.036” and 0.040” thick blade, respectively
  • Sharp, quality blades give a 1 1/8” wide cutting diameter, which makes for a great open wound and blood trail

CONS

  • Although these broadheads are sharp and sturdy and seem to fly just like a field point, as the distance increases, the tip tends to bend or break upon impact.

This Muzzy Bowhunting Broadhead features extremely impressive, 4 very sharp blades that guarantee a kill as soon as it hits the target. It comes in both 100 and 125-grain weights to provide the user with variety and choose according to their own preference. The 100-grain has a 0.036” thick blade while there is a 0.040” thick blade on the 125-grain head.

This model by Muzzy also features a secondary bleeder blade that itself is 0.028” thick. All these blades together give an astonishing 1 1/8” wide cutting diameter, which means significant blood loss to the animal, a better blood trail and ultimately, a quicker kill. There are 3 heads in each packet.

Bottom Line

This broadhead is a perfect tool for serious big game hunting that provides damaging penetration and overall, enhanced performance. It is an excellent option when it comes to finding a reliable 125-grain broadhead.

How to Sharpen Fixed Blade Broadheads?

It is good practice to sharpen blades after each practice session or before every hunt. There are 2 ways, however, on how to sharpen your fixed blade broadhead.

  1. Use a sharpening stone. (A sharpening stone is basically a two-sided flat stone.)
  2. Use a broadhead sharpener. (It is easy to use and much durable.)

With either of the two, all you need to do is apply a small amount of pressure while moving the head back and forth to shave off a small piece of the metal on every side of the blade bevel to get a fine, sharp edge. Make sure to repeat this on each side of the blade to get an evenly sharpened head.

Conclusion

High-quality, well-designed broadheads are essentials for a perfect kill as well as to keep the kills ethical. It is important that they are lightweight yet quick to have a lethal effect on the victim almost instantly. You can use the best fixed blade broadheads listed above to find the one that fits your needs best.

Leave a Comment