Best Ice Fishing Gloves of 2020 – Complete Review

Ice fishing is not easy; in fact, even simple fishing is not as easy as it seems. There is a lot of technique and of course, patience that goes into it. When you add the element of extreme weather on top of it, safety becomes paramount. 

And, on top should be the safety of your hands. You don’t want to end up in the emergency room because of frostbite. Thus, here we will be talking about the most important part that you need to protect i.e., your hands. We will review the best ice fishing gloves available to help you pick the best one.

Comparison Chart of the Best Ice Fishing Gloves

PRODUCTDETAILS
gm2-table__image

Big Worm Fishing Mens Neoprene Gloves

  • Designed with special grip surfacing for good hold in cold and wet conditions
  • Made with 5mm neoprane material to provide better insulation against cold
  • Comes in comfortable sizes ranging from large to extra-large
View Latest Price
gm2-table__image

KastKing Mountain Mist Fishing Gloves

  • Made with fleece-lined back and neoprene for comfort and heat insulation
  • Designed with exposable fingertips for dexterous practicality
  • Printed polymer palm patterning provides an improved grip
View Latest Price
gm2-table__image

Memphis Glove N9690FCL

  • Best for the Money
  • 15 gauge acryllic lined nylon shell with fully coated HPT foam sponge
  • Polyvinyl foam sponge used in palm design provides superior gripping ability
View Latest Price
gm2-table__image

WindRider Rugged Waterproof Winter Gloves

  • Best Waterproof Ice Fishing Gloves
  • Advanced construction featuring condura nylon shell with hipora liner thisulate insulation and inner fleece lining
  • Designed with practicality in mind that allows you to answer a touchscreen
View Latest Price
gm2-table__image

Palmyth Neoprene Fishing Gloves

  • Best Neoprene Ice Fishing Gloves
  • Made from stretchable breathing neoprene and windproofed material for snug fit and practical use
  • Artificial leather palm with specially textured surface provide a sturdy grip
View Latest Price

Should Any Gloves Be Used For Ice Fishing

In cold weather, your body preserves its heat and directs it to the more vital organs like lungs and heart. This causes your body to take heat away from parts of the body like the hand and feet, and as a result, they become cold, lose their mobility, and become susceptible to frostbite.

All that scary stuff is mentioned because your hands do all the work in fishing, and you need them at their best. For that, the best insulated and waterproof material is required. 

Not all gloves will do the job here. Some gloves are not made for harsh weather but normal winter conditions. And those that are for harsh weather might be so thick that you can’t properly move your fingers.    

You need a balance between both. The glove should be waterproof because you will be handling fish a lot, and it should allow your fingers to cast the line like they normally would.

How to Choose Gloves For Ice Fishing

Form the above section, you will have a pretty good idea of what an ice fishing glove should and shouldn’t have, but let’s break down all the main properties here.

Insulation

For keeping your hands warm and secure, this is the most important aspect of gloves. They should be able to keep the warmth of the hands. Good insulating materials include nylon, fleece, polyester, etc. 

Another thing that determines warmth and insulation is the number of layers or thickness of the gloves. The thicker they are, of course, the better they will protect you, but make sure not to go too thick.

Mobility

Because you need your hands for fishing and angling, you need to be able to move your hands and have a good grip on the fishing rod. Some gloves have small holes on the fingertips to let you tie knots and thread the line without having to fully remove the gloves. 

Since your gloves will be getting snow and maybe water on them, they should have some measure to keep your hands from slipping and letting go of the rod. The palm should be non-slip.

KastKing Mountain Mist Fishing Gloves

Fit

Having the proper size of gloves for your hands is important in all cases, including this. Without a good fit, you will not be comfortable. If they are too big, they can fall off, and if they are too small, they will be tight and not cover your hands properly. Measure your hands and compare the measurements to the size chart for the gloves you want to buy.

Material

Material plays an important part in determining how good and durable your gloves really are. Because we are going for warm and waterproof gloves, having fleece, neoprene, nylon and other synthetics like polyester will be the best bet.

Quick Take | Best Ice Fishing Gloves

Just looking for the top three best ice fishing gloves? Here they are:

  1. Big Worm Fishing Mens Neoprene Gloves
  2. KastKing Mountain Mist Fishing Gloves
  3. Memphis Glove N9690FCL

Review of the Best Ice Fishing Gloves

Having read the main qualities and benefits of ice fishing gloves, let’s look at the top ice fishing gloves. These have been reviewed in detail so that you can find out the one you want.  

PROS

  • Have a budget-friendly price
  • Made of waterproof neoprene material
  • Textured palm and finger area for good grip
  • Will fit most hands for both men and women
  • A multipurpose glove used for other outdoor activities

CONS

  • Only available in large and extra-large sizes

What Recent Buyers Report

There is nothing bad to say about these gloves. They are good at keeping the hands dry and warm. You also get to move your fingers easily. People use them not just for ice fishing but for all kinds of outdoor winter chores.

Why it Stands Out to Us

These gloves are designed to fit perfectly on to your hands. They have a soft lining on the inside, making them very comfortable to wear. The outer part on the palm area has a textured finish to give you a good grip on the fishing rod and also when you hold the fish, which can be very slimy. They are made of 3mm neoprene, which is a great insulator.   

Who Will Use This Most

Not only are these gloves unisex, but the sizes available are L to XL. Other than ice fishing, they can also be used for normal winter use, cycling, scuba diving, paddling, and fishing. Because of their waterproof nature, they have a multipurpose use, and they are not so thick that you cannot handle things with them.

Bottom Line

This is our top pick because these gloves are very low priced, given the fact they are made of waterproof neoprene. These check all the boxes for a good ice fishing glove, including warmth, keeping dry, comfortable, and mobility in the fingers.   

PROS

  • Has a non-slip microfiber palm
  • Comes with smartphone-friendly tips
  • Cuffs can be adjusted to your wrist size
  • Made of waterproof material lined with fleece
  • Finger slits on thumb, index, and middle finger

CONS

  • Only perfect for mildly cool weather

What Recent Buyers Report

These gloves are comfortable to wear and very durable. For mild winter conditions, they work perfectly. They will keep you warm and snug with the soft lining on the inside. Having openings on some of the fingers is a very convenient addition and helps when working. They also have a very good design and are not just plain.  

Why it Stands Out to Us

Because having a good grab on your rod is important while fishing (you don’t want the rod to fly off when a fish pulls on it from the other end), these gloves have an anti-slip palm that gives you a good grip. 

For additional warmth, the inside has a fleece lining that is soft and fluffy. It will keep you comfortable as well. It is also fully waterproof. For using phones and handling things like tying a knot, there are three fingers (thumb, middle, and index) that have a smartphone-friendly texture and a slit opening.  

Who Will Use This Most

This glove has the perfect thickness and warmth for mild winters but not for too extreme cold. Because it has open fingers, it can be worn normally when doing things like shoveling snow, etc. The smartphone-compatible fingertips also make them perfect for everyday use, including ice fishing.  

Bottom Line

The only thing about these gloves is that they are not for every weather condition. Other than that, they work perfectly and keep your hands warm. Their waterproofing ability is also very good and keeps you dry.

Best for the Money:
Memphis Glove N9690FCL

PROS

  • Treated with HTP liquid repellent
  • Coated with Actifresh to kill bacteria
  • Has level three ANSI cut and abrasion score
  • Material remains soft even at -85° F temperature
  • Available in four different sizes for different kinds of hands

CONS

  • No finger slits which this glove needs for handling small items

What Recent Buyers Report

Users report that these gloves are thick and will definitely keep you warm. They might be too thick for some people, but given the price, they do have good quality, and they work pretty well in most conditions. They are also waterproof and keep you dry. If you wash them regularly, they are the best.

Why it Stands Out to Us

These gloves have an inner liner made of 15 gauge black nylon and 7 gauge acrylic terry. These materials keep your hands warm and dry. The outer layer has a full coating of HPT (hydro repellent technology), which is a liquid repellent and keeps the glove from going rigid even in extremely low temperatures. 

It has ANSI (American National Standards Institute) ratings of 3-abrasion, 3-cut, and 2-puncture. This means it can withstand some heavy work conditions. In addition to all that, it also has Actifresh that kills bacteria caused by sweating and keeps bad odors away.    

Who Will Use This Most

We find this to be more for extremely low temperatures and harsh work conditions. If you live in such an area that gets these kinds of winters and you like to go fishing there, then these are definitely for you. Your hands will remain dry, warm, and will be able to move freely.

Bottom Line

For a pair of budget gloves, these are really well made and durable. If maintained properly, i.e., washed every other day, then they will last you a good while. They keep you warm and dry, and that is the main part.  

Best Waterproof Ice Fishing Gloves:
WindRider Rugged Waterproof Winter Gloves

PROS

  • Made of waterproof material
  • Has touchscreen-compatible tips
  • Elastic lightener on the wrist for comfort  
  • Breathable yet warm insulation of four layers
  • A storage pocket for keys and other small items

CONS

  • Touchscreen feature is not very precise

What Recent Buyers Report

Buyers love that this glove has many sizes, which is perfect for all. They are very comfortable to wear and have breathable material. Having a small pocket on them really helps with storing things that you use all the time and want to have quick access to. All in all, they are great and do what they are supposed to do.

Why it Stands Out to Us

While these gloves sure have the warmth and waterproofing feature like all others, they also have a small pocket on the backside. It is wide enough to store your credit cards easily. It is all about going that extra mile and giving your customers something different. 

With these gloves, you also get touchscreen compatibility on the thumb, index finger, and middle finger. For proper insulation, it has five different layers, i.e., waterproof layer, Cordura nylon shell, breathable Hipora liner, 70 grams Thinsulate, and soft fleece.

Who Will Use This Most

They are thick and comfortable with sizes for everyone’s hands. The gloves can withstand constant contact with snow and cold weather without your hands getting the slightest idea. Because it has touchscreen compatibility, you can use it anywhere and everywhere. They are also made for both men and women.   

Bottom Line

For waterproofing, these gloves are some of the best. Having five different layers with different functionalities really helps improve quality. They are very dependable and durable and can be used for all kinds of winter activities.  

Best Neoprene Ice Fishing Gloves:
Palmyth Neoprene Fishing Gloves

PROS

  • Palm area has a good grip
  • Adjustable cuffs for a more secure fit
  • Has breathable and windproof material
  • Made of stretch neoprene which offers a better fit
  • Finger slits for handling phone, wire and other things

CONS

  • Not completely waterproof

What Recent Buyers Report

Buyers love that these gloves are not fully insulated, but they are pretty good at keeping your hands clean when handling fish, and they also have a good grip. They are pretty inexpensive but of overall good quality. You can expect them to keep you comfortable in normal winters but not harsh ones.

Why it Stands Out to Us

This one is made of stretch neoprene, which gives your hands flexibility and fits them perfectly. For a good grip on the rod, the palm is made of artificial leather. So your hand will not slip. It also has an adjustable strap at the cuffs that you can use to fit your hands better. The middle finger and the thumb have slits if you want to use your phone or camera.

Who Will Use This Most

These are made for everyday use, including fishing. Removing the tips on two fingers gives you room to do different things like tying a knot and use your phone. The material that is used is windproof. You will be comfortable in weather that requires sweaters but maybe not in anything more. 

Bottom Line

If you are looking for more low key gloves and are not planning on going into any extreme weather, then these will fit perfectly. They will keep you dry enough and away from the slime of the fish since many people don’t like handling that. 

​What Do I Need To Know Before Buying?

By now, you know what you are looking for, but sometimes advertisers use confusing words to trick you. There are a lot of ways your research can go to waste. So, before making a final decision, look at some things that people tend to get wrong and what you shouldn’t.

Waterproof Index

Just because a glove says it’s waterproof doesn’t mean it is completely so. There are different ratings of waterproof material, and they are all used under different conditions. A 6000-10,000 mm rating means your glove can withstand light rain. The higher ratings mean it can also withstand snow and more pressure.

Size

Measuring your hands can be confusing. Different manufacturers have different size charts, but the basic steps are the same. The simplest is when you measure the width of your hands across the knuckles. 

Some size charts will say the circumference of your hands. In that case, you wrap the measuring tape around your hand at the knuckles area, and measure like you would make a circle.

Thinsulate

Thinsulate is a thermal insulation material used in clothes for warmth. This material is thinner yet denser than the traditional material used for insulation. The manufacturer will list the Thinsulate in terms of grams e.g., 40 grams. 40 grams is the minimum threshold. However, it is not the only insulating material, so it’s not necessary that your glove will have a layer of it.

Conclusion

In the end, all that is left to do is buy the glove and go fishing, and of course, to be safe. When buying the glove, you need to keep in mind the conditions under which you will be using them the most and go from there. 

Some people might find a glove perfect for them, but that doesn’t mean it’s the right one for you. Keeping all we have listed here in mind, choose the one that best fits your needs.  

People Also Ask

If there are more questions about ice fishing and the materials used in ice fishing gloves, then read these frequently asked questions for some insight.

Do I Need Waterproof Gloves For Ice Fishing?

Having waterproof gloves for ice fishing is very important. Just because it’s ice fishing doesn’t mean there is no water. If the material is not waterproof and your hands get wet from cold water, it will freeze.

Are Neoprene Gloves Warm?

Neoprene works a little differently than other materials. It provides warmth by trapping water, which is then heated by your body. The material is not breathable, so these gloves can get very sweaty.

How Do You Keep Your Hands Warm When Ice Fishing?

The perfect way of keeping the hands warm while ice fishing is by wearing the proper gloves. Some people also use hand warmers that they put inside their gloves.