Best Ice Fishing Boots of 2020 – Buyer’s Guide

Fishing in the ice is quite an adventurous sport, and if you’re visiting North America in the winter, you’ll surely want to enjoy it. But to be able to do that, you’ll need a sturdy pair of boots that’ll ensure a smooth fishing trip. In this article, we’re going to discuss some of the best ice fishing boots on the market. 

Comparison Chart of the Best Ice Fishing Boots

PRODUCTDETAILS
gm2-table__image

Muck Boot Arctic Winter Boot

  • Provides superior warmth with 2mm thermal foam underlay added to the instep
  • Molded rubber shell provides a full seal for waterproofing and warmth
  • Addditional warmth provided by 5mm neoprene and fleece linning
View Latest Price
gm2-table__image

Baffin Men's All-Weather Boot

  • Removable linings help adjust for warmer temperatures
  • Memory foam insole provides enhanced comfort
  • Lightweight and slim design for better moving around
View Latest Price
gm2-table__image

Silentcare Men's Snow Boots

  • Best for the Money
  • Made from durable and water-resistant material
  • Inner lining is warm but still breathable
View Latest Price
gm2-table__image

Baffin Men's Impact Insulated Boot

  • Warmest Ice Fishing Boots
  • Boots are surprisingly lightweight but still very warm
  • Unique honeycomb design traps air under the foot
View Latest Price
gm2-table__image

Columbia Women's Ice Maiden II

  • Best Women's Ice Fishing Boots
  • Omni-Grip traction of rubber sole promises slip-free movement
  • Made from waterproof and durable leather
View Latest Price
gm2-table__image

Baffin Men's Wolf Snow Boot

  • Best Baffin Ice Fishing Boots
  • Insulation is durable and washable
  • Buckles make tightening and loosening very easy
View Latest Price

Will Any Boots Work For Ice Fishing?

You can’t use any kind of boots for ice fishing due to several reasons. Those that are made specifically for ice fishing have certain features that make them special. For example, they are much thicker to provide better insulation, so your feet don’t freeze in the cold. 

Another thing they are crucial for is their ability to help you stay upright instead of slipping on the ice. This is possible because of their sturdy soles and deep tracks. 

They will also keep your feet dry in case you step into the water. All these characteristics need to be taken into account when going ice fishing. Therefore, you cannot just rely on any kind of boots.

How to Choose Ice Fishing Boots

If you want to make the right choice in purchasing a pair of excellent ice fishing boots, there are some factors you’ll need to keep in mind. These will help your boots last longer and ensure you got the best out of money. So let’s get into them. 

Boot Insulation

This is one of the most important characteristics. You’ll have to spend long hours in the cold when fishing; therefore, it is wise to keep your feet warm and, thus, your entire body warm

Depending upon how harsh the weather is, different types have different layers of insulation. You’ll need a warmer pair for a much cooler environment.

Boot Stiffness

The more rigid your boots, the longer they’re last. They’ll also keep pressure off of your body and function better on rough surfaces. Rubber options can be flimsy and bend easily; therefore, they won’t be handy for too long. 

Material and Durability

You’ll need to check whether you need some made of synthetic materials, leather, or rubber. The material determines longevity. Leather will give you the best out of your money and will last the longest.

Whether They Are Waterproof

You want them to be comfortable. There’s always the risk of wetting your boots in ice, so you want to buy waterproof boots. 

Size

Since you’ll be wearing socks underneath, you’ll need to size up. If you plan on getting thicker socks, order a size or two up.     

Quick Take | Best Ice Fishing Boots

Just looking for the top three best ice fishing boots? Here they are:

  1. Muck Boot Arctic Winter Boot
  2. Baffin Men's All-Weather Boot
  3. Silentcare Men's Snow Boots

Review of the Best Ice Fishing Boots

If you have finally decided to purchase these boots, congratulations! We will now move on to review the top-recommended options on the market. Let’s get into the nitty-gritty details that will certainly help you out into making the best decision and eliminate any confusion that you may otherwise have. 

PROS

  • Quite light in weight and flexible
  • Completely waterproof, making them ideal to use around the ice 
  • Can be used in temperatures as low as -40 to -60 degrees Fahrenheit 
  • Made with a 2 mm thermal foam for additional insulation and warmth
  • Sole is made of rubber, giving you steady traction especially of slippery ice

CONS

  • Size range is quite narrow
  • Since they are made of rubber, their flexibility can reduce their longevity

What Recent Buyers Report

It would be an understatement to claim that users really like their Muck boots. They are quite comfortable and keep your feet warm for long. Their ruggedness increases their longevity and aptness for rough, icy surfaces. All in all, users highly recommend them and find it a great idea to give them as a present as well.        

Why it Stands Out to Us

The Muck boots have been here for a while and have made their name in the market. Users trust the brand for good reason. With a thick layer of foam-padded at the sole of the boot, you can be assured that your feet will stay warm in very low temperatures and for long time periods.   

Who Will Use This Most

Since the shaft measures up to 14.5 inches, the boots can go up as high as your knees. This makes them suitable in deep snow or water, especially since they are 100% waterproof as well. They can also be used in temperatures as low as -40 to -60 degrees Fahrenheit, so they are a good option for ice fishing or hunting in the snow.

Bottom Line

Made to be rugged, durable, and warm, the Muck winter pair is rated the best for ice fishing. You wouldn’t need to worry about getting a new pair for a couple of years and practically do anything in the ice or snow for as long as you like!  

PROS

  • Come with excellent traction and grip
  • Quite lightweight, soft and comfortable
  • Removable liners and hooks make it easy to pull them out
  • Made with 100% leather for increased durability and a good look
  • Sole is made with advanced thermo-set polymers for added warmth and comfort

CONS

  • Some people find these too expensive
  • Usually, run a size small so you might want to size up when purchasing 

What Recent Buyers Report

One of the most durable products anyone has used, these all-weather boots are popular amongst many users. Many buyers have reported that they have been using them in rugged conditions for more than five years and couldn’t be happier. They highly recommend these for their longevity and ability to withstand low temperatures.

Why it Stands Out to Us

These are surprisingly made with the latest technology. They are made of fabric and leather, and the sole is foam-based, which increases its warmth threefold. The sole is quite rigid to prevent slippage, but at the same time, it is soft and comfortable. They truly give you exceptional grip and warmth, all together.

Who Will Use This Most

Made with new technology, these are rugged enough to withstand temperatures as low as -94 Fahrenheit. They also reach up to your knees so you can get into the deep layers of snow with them. Unlike many snow boots, there is a wide range of sizes available in these.

Bottom Line

Featuring top-notch leather and fabric, these boast a sleek look while providing ultimate comfort. If you can’t find your size in other options, these are a great fit. They’ll not only last you a long time but will also help you stay warm in the coolest temperatures.

Best for the Money:
Silentcare Men's Snow Boots

PROS

  • Lined with artificial fur to keep your feet warm
  • Completely water-resistant, which adds to the durability 
  • A reflective stripe at the back enables them to be used in the dark as well
  • Zipper on the sides instead of laces, so they are quicker and easier to put on
  • Toe cap has protection so that your toe is not hurt (for example, when you kick a rock)

CONS

  • Quite stiff and not flexible
  • Zipper breaks with a few uses

What Recent Buyers Report

Being one of the cheapest options, these are a popular choice amongst buyers. They not only look fashionable, but the fur inside makes them extremely warm and comfortable. Also, they are made of tough material to last for several months. 

Why it Stands Out to Us

These may look cute but are quite rugged. They are water-resistant to help keep your feet dry, have zippers on the side for your ease, and toe protection so that your toe does not get injured if you hit something. With everything you need for ice fishing, these boots are a steal at such a low price.

Who Will Use This Most

If you’re bad at tying laces or are always in a hurry, these are a good choice for you. Since they are ankle boots, they are best used on ice and not necessarily in deep snow. Plus, being water-resistant makes them suitable in watery surfaces.       

Bottom Line

All in all, if you’re just looking for a pair of boots for a vacation or don’t want to invest a great deal of money into this, then these are a good option. They’ll keep you warm and help you fish in the ice without you having to break the bank!

Warmest Ice Fishing Boots:
Baffin Men's Impact Insulated Boot 

PROS

  • Come in two different colors/designs
  • A snow collar to prevent snow from gathering inside 
  • Feature an 8-layer inner boot system with Thermaplush
  • Made to be quite durable and can last for more than 20 years
  • Can keep you warm in temperatures as low as -148 degrees Fahrenheit

CONS

  • Top part of the boot is not waterproof
  • Built to be a size down so you’ll need to size up when purchasing

What Recent Buyers Report

These boots have exceeded buyers’ expectations. Many users found the whole purchasing experience quite joyful. They say it is easy to order them, and everything from the packaging to customer service was very super. Users also love that they last a long time.   

Why it Stands Out to Us

Baffin has built these boots to absolute perfection. The 8 layers of Thermaplush insulation make them ultra-comfortable and the ability to be worn in extremely low temperatures.

When it comes to the sole, it is the only part of the boot that is waterproof. The G-flex midsole is made with flexible rubber while the outsole increases the boot’s traction and grip. All of this makes this the perfect boot for ice fishing.  

Who Will Use This Most

If you’re going to, say, Alaska in the winters, you’d definitely be facing quite low temperatures, and for that, you would need durable boots. Without a doubt, this is one of the warmest pair you can get that’ll keep your feet insulated at as low as -148 degrees Fahrenheit.   

Bottom Line

To sum up, if you’re looking for a product that’ll last you a long while and you wouldn’t need to invest in another pair for at least two more decades, you need to invest in these. Trust us when we tell you that they are the warmest, most comfortable ones on the market! 

Best Women's Ice Fishing Boots:
Columbia Women's Ice Maiden II

PROS

  • Lightweight as well as water-resistant
  • Made with high-quality leather and rubber 
  • Feature 200 grams of insulation for maximum warmth
  • Promise advanced traction with their signature Omni-GRIP
  • Have a soft faux fur collar so that snow does not get inside

CONS

  • Design is not the best for unisex use
  • Some users have complained that they aren’t waterproof

What Recent Buyers Report

Women, in particular, are quite happy that there is a pair of ice fishing boots designed especially for them. Unlike other choices, these ones aren’t too heavy-duty, so you wouldn’t feel like you’re carrying a cast around. The best part is that they look good with any outfit on!

Why it Stands Out to Us

These are quite versatile, but that’s not the only thing we love about them. Columbia’s exquisite Omni-GRIP technology uses a multi-zone tread pattern to assure the right grip for any kind of surface, no matter how rough or rugged. This technology makes these boots perfect for icy and snowy surfaces and ensures no slipping!         

Who Will Use This Most

The style and design are targeted at women. These are very comfortable and durable. If you’re planning on visiting a place with uneven ice or even going inside a glacier, these are perfect for you as they have the best traction. 

Bottom Line

These are some of the best, and we particularly love how they perform in rugged terrains. They are warm, water-resistant, and comfortable, so there isn’t much else you’d want in a cold-weather boot. So don’t sleep on these, and get them today!

Best Baffin Ice Fishing Boots:
Baffin Men's Wolf Snow Boot

PROS

  • Made with 100% Nylon and leather
  • Come with 7 layers of inner boot insulation
  • Provide excellent grip and are quite durable and efficient
  • A snow collar with a drawstring so they can be closed off 
  • Lined with velvet-smooth Thermaplush for added warmth

CONS

  • Some people find that water does seep inside these
  • Many users have complained about their customer service

What Recent Buyers Report

At this price, users are extremely impressed with these boots. Lightweight and comfortable, they do exactly what they’re meant for. Most importantly, they last for years on and so you wouldn’t need to invest in a new pair any time soon. Buyers highly recommend these.

Why it Stands Out to Us

We have listed 3 Baffin products in this article for a reason – they never disappoint. With the Wolf Snow Boot, Baffin has chosen leather and Nylon for ultimate protection and design.

These have excellent traction and are quite rugged. They have a snow collar with a drawstring, so you needn’t worry about snow seeping into your feet.

Who Will Use This Most

Baffin’s Wolf Snow Boots can tolerate temperatures as low as -40 degrees Fahrenheit. They are great for ice fishing but are multi-purpose and can be used on any snowy or icy surfaces. They cover your leg almost up to the knee, as well as their shaft measures about 11 inches from the arch.  

Bottom Line

These are Baffin’s finest boots. This brand is a reliable one, and this product, in particular, is at the top with a very impressive build. With velvet-smooth Thermaplush and 7 layers of inner boot insulation, you’re guaranteed maximum warmth and comfort. At such a reasonable price, these are definitely worth purchasing.

Advantages of Investing in a Quality Pair of Ice Fishing Boots

You may still be thinking about why you should invest in a pair of ice fishing boots. Well, here are some reasons.  

Warmth

You’ll be spending many hours when fishing, and that means being exposed to the cold. A quality pair of boots will keep your feet warm at temperatures even below zero degrees Celsius. And if your feet are warm, your body will remain warm as well.

Plus, since they have multiple layers of insulation, they will keep your feet warm and save you from getting frostbite.   

Also, they are usually lined with Thermaplush and layers of insulation to ensure your feet and body are at a normal temperature. 

Stability

The soles on these products are made stronger, and they have better traction so you can be stable on ice surfaces without slipping. 

Keep You Dry 

In case you step into the water, they will prevent your feet from getting too wet and your socks from being soggy. 

A good product will last you a long time; hence they are definitely a worthy investment.

Conclusion 

All that’s left now is for you to make your decision and choose the perfect ice fishing boots. We have enlisted the top picks on the market, each of them has its own unique quality, and there’s a price range that can fit any budget. We hope you find one that can do the task perfectly. Happy shopping!

People Also Ask  

In case you have certain queries, we have rounded up some of the most frequently asked questions and tried to respond to them as thoroughly as we can. We hope this article is detailed enough to help clear up any doubts you have. 

Are Muck Boots Good For Ice Fishing?

Muck Boots are the ideal choice for ice fishing since they are made of rubber. They are flexible, comfortable, and can cover icy, snowy, and even muddy surfaces, making them some of the most versatile options. The rubber soles help with better traction and grip on ice, and that’s why we have added them in our top recommendations. 

How Do I Keep My Feet Warm When Ice Fishing?

You can start by investing in a good quality pair of cold weather boots. We have given several reasons as to why this is a good idea, the main one being that they are often lined with Thermaplush or warm material to insulate your feet. You must also wear thick socks that’ll further help out.

How Do You Keep Your Feet Dry in Boots?

Most cold weather boots are water-resistant since they are made of materials such as rubber. They prevent any water from seeping inside. Some also have a snow collar, maybe even a drawstring, so that snow does not enter. You could also cover your boots in plastic bags to keep your feet dry.