The Best Ice Fishing Bibs | Buyer’s Guide for 2019

Have you ever experienced the extreme shock of freezing cold water rushing into your fishing boots as you stepped through some thin ice on a cold winter’s day? If you have, you’ll appreciate the importance of the right fishing bib to keep you safe, warm, and dry while ice angling.

We’ll break down the factors you should consider when buying an ice bib and also share our top picks for the best ice fishing bibs that will protect you from the elements on a trip.

Comparison Chart of the Best Ice Fishing Bibs

PRODUCT DETAILS
gm2-table__image

​Arctix Men's Overalls Tundra Bib With Added Visibility

  • Best overall
  • 100% polyester material
  • Weighs 85 grams or 2.99 ounces
View Latest Price
gm2-table__image

​​Frabill I3 Bib

  • Runner-up
  • 10,000 mm waterproof index
  • Made of denier nylon material
View Latest Price
gm2-table__image

​Frogg Toggs Pilot II Camo Bib

  • Best for the money
  • Made of Teflon DWR polyester
  • Has a 15,000 mm waterproof index
View Latest Price
gm2-table__image

Grunden's Men’s Weather Watch Bib

  • Material is machine washable
  • Made of 100% nylon material
  • Comes in many sizes and colors
View Latest Price
gm2-table__image

IceArmor by Clam Edge Bib for Men

  • Has a rapid drainage system
  • Denier water and windproof shell
  • Pockets are lined with fleece for warmth
View Latest Price

Are Bibs Important While Ice Fishing?

Fishing bibs not only keep you dry, but they also protect you from cold and wind. Ice fishing can get very cold, and if you don’t dress properly, you could get hypothermia. Quality bibs are made of a material that will keep your body warm and not let any moisture in. They are not just latex covers to keep you dry, but they also let the internal moisture like perspiration be released. This helps maintain normal body temperature. It is always vital to protect yourself first.

It is, therefore, important to wear the right fishing bib. You need to know which one will fit you and which one will be best for the place you are going to.

What is an Ice Fishing Bib Used For? 

Like every recreational activity, ice fishing becomes more enjoyable and rewarding when you have the right equipment.

Because ice fishing is often done in bitterly cold conditions, keeping warm and dry is paramount in order to safely enjoy your day.

Ice fishing bibs are specifically designed for this activity, with plenty of insulation and other features to keep you dry and warm in freezing or sub-zero temperatures.

While standing or sitting still for long periods of time while fishing, you have a high risk of frostbite or hypothermia if your body is exposed to the biting winds, cold air, and water.

Ice bibs will protect you from getting hurt or sick due to the cold weather and you should definitely consider getting one for your next ice fishing expedition.

Choosing the Best Ice Fishing Bib

Not all ice fishing bibs are created equally. Some emphasize durability and insulation while others have extra features that can come in handy for some fishermen. Let’s look at the factors that will influence your decision on which one to get.

Insulation

Insulation is important for your ice fishing trips because standing in biting cold winds will deprive you of body heat very quickly. The wind chill factor, combined with already freezing temperatures, can lead to hypothermia or frostbite.

A well-insulated bib will prevent you from losing body heat and will allow you to withstand harsh weather. Look for bibs with Thinsulate or fleece linings.

Does it Float?

Not every bib is designed to float. This feature proves its worth when you fall into the water and need to stay afloat. They may look like any other ice fishing bib, but floating bibs can save your life!

Is it Waterproof?

Just as the bib should keep you warm, it also needs to keep out the rain, snow, and water. Look for a bib that has a waterproof coating or layer.

With differing levels of waterproofing available, you should check what level of water protection is offered by the bib before you purchase. Bibs will provide you protection from rain ranging from a light drizzle to a heavy downpour.  

Does it Have Padded Knees?

Angling requires sitting, standing, and kneeling on occasion, so having reinforced knees on your bib will help protect your knees in case you fall or need to kneel on the ice.

Reflective Material or Lining

For increased visibility at night, it is recommended to get a bib with reflective tape or lining. This will make you safer when angling in the dark.

Other Features

Try to get a bib that’s lightweight, so you will not experience issues in moving around freely. It should also be durable, comfortable, and have room for layers of clothing underneath.

Depending on the weather, you might need additional clothing underneath the bib for additional insulation.

Quick Take | Best Ice Fishing Bibs

Just looking for the top three best ice fishing bibs? Here they are:

  1. Arctix Men's Overalls Tundra Bib With Added Visibility
  2. Frabill I3 Bib
  3. Frogg Toggs Pilot II Camo Bib

Review of the Best Ice Fishing Bibs

We’ve gone through the many options available in the market and rounded up the best ones.

Arctix Men's Tundra Ballistic Bib Overalls With Added Visibility, Black, Large

PROS

  • This is a very lightweight product
  • A boot zipper for easy removal and put on
  • Boot gaiters to keep the feet dry and warm
  • Has seat and knees, friction and scuff guards
  • Polyester garment makes it warm and waterproof
  • Plenty of Pocket Space
  • Insulated for Warmth
  • Waterproof up to 5K M/M
  • Night Visibility with Reflective Stripes

CONS

  • It does not have many size options
  • The Elastic Bands Become Loose Throughout the Day Once Adjusted

What Recent Buyers Report 

People are surprised by the level of protection and warmth it provides. Even after years of usage, the most error they could find was a broken zipper. No moisture gets in, and the skin remains protected from burns. The extra pockets also helped store keys and kept hands warm.

Why it Stands Out to Us 

These are heavy-duty multi-layered bibs that are ultra-lightweight. They use microchambers in the fabric to keep the wearer warm and dry even in extended use. It is laminated with a waterproof material that is also breathable so that your body moisture can evaporate and not build up inside. Ankle, scuff, and hem guard made of ballistic-nylon make it durable and resistant to tears.

Our top pick is the Tundra Bib from Arctix, which is made of 100% Polyester Ballistic and contains W/R + W/P 5000mm ThermaLock Coating and 85 grams of ThermaTech Insulation.

The bib is both lightweight and warm, with plenty of padding and reinforcement at the points where you may experience wear and tear.

The 20" boot zipper makes removing and putting on shoes easy and the trouser legs integrate seamlessly with boots to keep warmth in and moisture out.

For increased comfort, the bibs have zippered hand-warmer pockets and feature reflective safety webbing for night visibility. The 85 grams of ThermaTech insulation keeps you cozy in the coldest weather.

Aside from that, the bib is breathable and windproof. These relaxed-fit pants are machine washable, making them perfect for outdoor activities.

Who Will Use This Most 

This bib keeps out not only water but also snow and is windproof. This heavy-duty construction saves you from all kinds of weather conditions. If you plan on wearing it at night time, then this bib has an additional feature of reflective webbing for visibility.

Bottom Line

This is our top pick for ice fishing bibs. Arctix has kept all your comfort and safety in mind while making this high-performance outerwear. It is 100% insulated, with sealed hems and improved mobility. And it all comes at a low price as well.

Offering great value, this bib is the perfect one for the ice fishing enthusiast who values comfort and safety and will not compromise on quality.

Runner-up:
Frabill I3 Bib

Frabill 2505041 Ice Fishing Safety Gear

PROS

  • Good waterproof index for breathability
  • Made of lightweight denier material
  • Uses 100% seam sealing for protection
  • Has knee and seat paddings on the inside
  • Zipper vents to regulate the temperature of the body
  • Waterproof
  • Windproof
  • Comfortable
  • Plenty of Storage Space

CONS

  • No size options available
  • Sizing Issues
  • No Fly Opening due to Being Waterproof

What Recent Buyers Report 

People living in a snowy area wear this product when the temperature outside is 10 degrees, and they are perfectly warm. The price is also not too much. This gets overall good reviews. People use it for all kinds of outdoor activities like fishing and hunting. Users also report that the material is strong and resistant to any wear and tear.

Why it Stands Out to Us 

The seams are completely sealed to ensure no moisture gets in that way. It is resistant to cold weather and will keep you warm. It is also very lightweight with zippers and knee cuffs to make it more comfortable. The shoulder straps can be easily adjusted, and it has paddings and warm pockets to keep you safe and dry.

This bib is waterproof, windproof, and breathable, with a 300 denier nylon shell, YKK Zippers, 500 denier nylon reinforced knees and pant cuffs, 150g 3M Thinsulate insulation, and full elastic shoulder straps with cam lock buckles. For additional durability, the bib has internal knee and seat padding, and for comfort, it has hand warmer pockets and zipper vents for temperature regulation.

You can put away your gadgets and gear in the spacious cargo pockets, and stay safe at night with the 3M Scotchlite reflective material. It includes a self-rescue set: ice pick holsters, ice safety internal label, and drainage mesh.

Who Will Use This Most 

This bib has reflective material for use at night time. It also comes with a rescue kit that has drainage mesh and ice pick holsters. If you are going fishing in extreme weather, you can be sure to be warm, dry, and safe in it.

Bottom Line

Our second pick for ice fishing bibs comes with extra safety features and equipment. The zipper vents and paddings, along with elastic shoulder straps, all ensure your comfort and safety. The material is also completely waterproof, windproof, and breathable.

With plenty of insulation and other features, this bib is no slouch! Opt for the Frabill I3 if you need a warm, comfortable, and waterproof bib for all kinds of weather conditions.

Frogg Toggs Pilot II Guide Bib, Red/Black, Size X-Large

PROS

  • A lot of storage pockets
  • Breathable, lightweight and flexible
  • Suspenders and waist are adjustable
  • Ankle-to-knee zips to make the taking off and putting on easier
  • Inner layer is made of micro-textured tricot fabric to reduce skin contact
  • Lightweight
  • Keeps you Dry
  • Layering is Possible with the Right Size
  • Side Pockets are Deep and Easy to Access

CONS

  • They are not very durable
  • Zipper is a Little Difficult to Operate in the Rain
  • We Found That One Customer Complained About it Leaking after One Season

What Recent Buyers Report 

There are many pockets in this bib, and that comes in handy for everyone. People wear it in snowy and windy weather, and with appropriate undergarments, it keeps them warm all day. Also, the different sizes allow everyone to be able to use it. Many people have exchanged sizes for a better fit.

Why it Stands Out to Us

This bib is low-priced but still keeps all your requirements in mind. It is very comfortable with adjustable suspenders, waist, and ankle-to-knee zips. All this makes mobility and usage easy. It also has ample room for your accessories with the expandable cargo pockets, D-rings, and chest-storage. The Teflon-coated polyester and micro-textured inner fabric make it seem very light.  

The Pilot Frogg Guide bibs are designed for the worst weather conditions and are both waterproof and breathable. They are made from 3-layer submersible material, with 100% seam sealed, full-zip front entry, and thigh-length leg zips for putting them on and taking them off easily.

In addition, you can adjust the Y-suspenders and waist for a more comfortable fit. They are lightweight enough for mobility while giving you storage options via the expandable cargo pockets and zippered chest storage pockets.

Who Will Use This Most 

This comes in many different sizes for both men and women. It can handle harsh weather and is resistant to any wear and tear. You can use it for any outdoor activity in cold weather. Hunting and fishing are the most common. It is also affordable, so if you are on a budget, you can invest in these.

Bottom Line

This bib gives all the necessary protection and warmth features you need from this product, all while maintaining a low price. It comes in many different colors and sizes for everyone. The waterproof and breathability index is standard and not too low, as well. 

While it doesn’t have much insulation, this bib will protect you from the elements and can fit layers of clothes within to ensure you stay toasty on the coldest days. It is not as durable as some others, though, so factor that in if you plan to use it for a long time.

Grundéns Men's Weather Watch Fishing Bib Trousers, Red - Small

PROS

  • Has adjustable leg cuffs
  • Suspenders can be adjusted
  • Elastic side gussets for mobility
  • Very lightweight and comfortable
  • Fully taped seams to ensure water protection
  • Durable
  • Breathable
  • Waterproof
  • Comfortable and Easy to Move While Wearing

CONS

  • More expensive than others
  • Not Insulated
  • Not Designed for Flotation

What Recent Buyers Report 

The bib is pretty strong and sturdy for its weight. People attach many things like keys, radios on it, and it holds. The price is also very reasonable. It doesn’t let your body temperature gets too warm, so people have also been wearing it in spring and autumn seasons without complaints because keeping dry is important in any weather when fishing.

Why it Stands Out to Us 

This bib uses nylon material and oxford weave to make it comfortable, lightweight, and durable. It has a Durable Water Repellent (DWR) coating that ensures your body remains dry and maintains is normal temperature. The seams are fully sealed to prevent any moisture from getting in and to make it wind-resistant as well. It takes care of the comfort of the wearer by adjustable spenders, ankle cuffs, and elastic side gussets.  

The Weather Watch Bib is made from 8k/3k waterproof, breathable, 420D Nylon Oxford weave fabric. It has fully taped seams, adjustable suspenders, and the hook-and-loop cinch ankle closures are adjustable. It offers plenty of storage in the leg cargo pocket and interior zippered chest pocket.

Being light, yet tough, the bib is durable and provides protection against the elements while the breathable construction prevents sweating and overheating. It can be rolled into a tight bundle and yet covers all of you and performs well in the heaviest of rains.

Who Will Use This Most 

This is used for fishing, mostly in cold weather. Its construction ensures internal moisture to get out, which is needed in outdoor activities. It is very comfortable and completely waterproof and comes in various sizes and colors for every body type. However, it’s not suitable for too extreme weather.

Bottom Line

This bib is designed to ensure a dry, warm, and safe experience. It ensures that your body remains 100% waterproof and windproof. It is also lightweight, breathable, and easy to use. That is really all you need from a bib, making this one an excellent pick. 

Choose this bib if you plan to wear layers inside, and are looking for something that works in both cold and warm weather.

It is great for outdoor activities that involve exposure to the elements and will keep you dry and comfortable in all sorts of rainy weather.

PROS

  • Storm gaiters to keep feet dry
  • Suspenders are adjustable for comfort
  • Scotchlite reflective elements for use at night
  • Lightweight and comfortable with padded knees
  • Ankle-to-waist zipper with magnetic flap for easy on and off
  • Well Insulated
  • Plenty of Storage
  • Knee and Seat Padding
  • Full-Length Zip-Up Legs
  • Reflective Material Suitable for Night Fishing

CONS

  • It is much more expensive
  • Some Customers are Dissatisfied with the Length of the Zip-Up Leg

What Recent Buyers Report 

These bibs are reported to be reliable and warm. They last for years, even after daily use. They are easy to use with all the zips and adjustable suspenders. People also love that there is plenty of room to keep their things. It certainly meets expectations and does not disappoint.

Why it Stands Out to Us 

This bib uses 300D waterproof material that ensures breathability. It is also comfortable and durable with 1000D nylon knee patches and paddings. It has internally lined pockets to keep hands warm and two-way zippers, adjustable inseam, adjustable suspenders, and storm gaiters for ease of use and comfort.   

This bib comes in bright and vivid colors and has plenty of insulation for keeping you warm while ice fishing. Offering comfort, mobility, and convenience, the bib has a tough 300D waterproof, windproof, breathable shell, and reinforced and padded, 1,000D ballistic nylon knee patches which make kneeling more comfortable.  

Ease of use is enhanced by the 2-way front zipper, fleece-lined hand-warmer pockets, long 2-way leg zips, adjustable inseam system with storm gaiters, and adjustable nylon suspenders with quick-release clasps. There’s even a built-in rapid drainage system for wet or slushy days. The fitting of the bib is also comfortable and allows for easy movement.

Who Will Use This Most 

This is made for outdoor ice activities. It ensures warmth and protection in extreme weather. Thus, you can use it for ice fishing, hunting, snowboarding, and other activities as well. There are different sizes available for every body type.

Bottom Line

This is our last pick for the ice fishing bibs, but that doesn’t mean that it’s not as good as the others. When it comes to comfort, warmth, safety, and dryness, it does its job well. Plus, the manufacturers use ballistic nylon with padding to ensure water protection and maintain a low weight.  

While not ideal for extreme cold, this bib will keep you warm in sub-zero temperatures and you can add additional layers inside if needed.

The well-padded and thoughtfully designed bib is sure to be a great hit with ice anglers looking for some storage for their tools and equipment.

Stormr Strykr Bib, Smoke, XXX-Large - Fishing, Fly Fishing & Ice Fishing

PROS

  • Flotation
  • Waterproof
  • Lightweight
  • Highly Adjustable

CONS

  • The Size Chart on their Website is Unreliable

Made from 100% polyester,  this bib has adjustable shoulder straps, a vented back panel, and two fleece-lined chest hand-warmer rests.

Combined with the matching jacket, this waterproof bib can provide almost head-to-toe protection in even the harshest weather.

The bib uses an abrasion-resistant material in high contact areas, features 3M reflective graphics, and nearly five pounds of positive buoyancy. So you can now enjoy warmth, flotation, and flexibility in one great package.

Bottom Line

With plenty of insulation and extra features like positive buoyancy, this bib gives great value and will be an asset to any angler in rough weather. Just double check the size with the seller before purchasing, as their stated sizing may not be reliable.

What Do I Need to Know Before Buying?

Some important things you should keep in mind when buying an ice fishing bib are:

Waterproof Level

Your bib’s main purpose is to keep you dry and warm. If it doesn’t do that, then nothing else matters. Normally these have a waterproof index of 11,000 to 15,000. This is the pressure at which water is able to press through and is measured in mm. This range ensures breathability while keeping you dry. Always wear insulating layers to keep warm. They also have pockets to store your things and keep your hands warm.

Mobility

You should be able to move around in your bib, or fishing could get very difficult and annoying. Some bibs provide for this by various stitches and design improvements that help you stay comfortable. The materials used are usually flexible.

Size

The bib should be your normal clothing size. If it is too big, you will slip and fall, and if it is too small, your entire body will not be protected. So, of course, buying the right size for you is essential.

Durability

If you are going to be using this every day or in extreme weather, the bib needs to be strong and durable. It should handle all the snow and wind and last you a long time. The value for money in any product is important. Most of these are made of ballistic nylon and micro-textured to make then light and comfortable while remaining strong. 

Conclusion

With several options for ice fishing bibs made from modern materials that will keep you both warm and comfortable, you have no more excuses to get cold or wet this ice fishing season. So what are you waiting for?

Just keep in mind our tips for selecting the right bib while shopping for an ice fishing bib so that it offers the right features. Go for bibs that are well insulated, waterproof, and float, so that you remain safe and comfortable while having fun fishing on the ice.