Best Crossbow Broadheads – 2019 Top Picks Reviewed

When looking to head out into the field for a hunt, you need to know you have the best gear for what you are doing.

Dragging a crossbow out with you can only do so much good if you don’t have the right broadheads to do the job.

That’s where we come in to help. We've reviewed the top broadheads on the market and given some helpful tips to make choosing the right ones for you an easier task. 

Comparison Chart of the Best Crossbow Broadheads

PRODUCT
gm2-table__image

Wasp Archery Sharpshooter Traditional 150 Grain Broadhead

  • Best Overall
  • Blade Lock System
  • Solid Steel Ferrules
View Latest Price
gm2-table__image

Maifield Archery Broadheads 100 Grain

  • Runner-up
  • Enhanced Flight Stability
  • High Quality Carrying Case
View Latest Price
gm2-table__image

Sinbadteck Hunting Broadheads

  • Quality Material
  • Best for the Money
  • Screw-in Compatible
View Latest Price
gm2-table__image

Barnett Cross Gamecrusher Broadheads 100 Grain

  • Trophy Tip
  • Offset Blades
  • Best for Barnett
View Latest Price
gm2-table__image

Rage Bowhunting CrossbowX Mechanical Broadhead

  • Two Versions
  • Shock Collar Technology
  • Best Mechanical Broadheads
View Latest Price
gm2-table__image

Excalibur Boltcutter 150 Grain 3-Blade Broadhead

  • High Speed Crossbows
  • Best Turkey Broadheads
  • Preassembled Broadheads
View Latest Price
gm2-table__image

Muzzy Bowhunting Trocar Crossbow Broadheads 3 Blade, 1-3/16 Inch Cutting Diameter

  • Contact Cut Tip
  • Helix Blade Design
  • Best 100 Grain Broadheads
View Latest Price
gm2-table__image

Rage Bowhunting Hypodermic Crossbow Mechanical Broadhead

  • Hybrid Tip
  • Best from Rage
  • Improved Shock Collar Technology
View Latest Price

Aspects to Consider Before Buying Broadheads

Now that you are ready to look for broadheads  to use for the upcoming season, there are some factors you should take into consideration before choosing.

Trajectory 

When looking to buy, think of where and how you like to hunt. If you prefer to shoot from a distance, take into consideration that the larger the surface of the broadhead, the more wind it will catch and your shot may be thrown off target by this.

Strength

You will need to make sure the ones you buy are of good quality material that is durable and can withstand hitting bone without breaking. The material also needs to keep its edge sharp so you are not always having to sharpen the blades.

Number of Blades

The number of blades is important as it will also affect how much wind the arrow will catch. While this can be bad, it is however, good to have more blades because it increases the chances of leaving a traceable blood trail if you don’t hit anything vital on the first shot.

What Can You Expect From Using Broadheads

Now that you have looked at some aspects, it is time to think about why you should be using them and what you can get out of an investment in quality models.

Humane Kills

One of the benefits of using these is the size of the wound they deliver. They typically leave larger holes than the arrow shaft, allowing for quick blood loss. This is a good this because it puts the animal out of its misery much quicker, providing a humane ending. It also allows you to track the animal easier due to a distinct blood trail.

Accuracy

Broadheads, whether they are mechanical or fixed, offer good stability in flight, providing you with better accuracy for your shot and making it more likely you will be able to hit your target and not have to be overly concerned about crosswinds, although they still can affect the flight trajectory.

Quality Material

Most are made out of stainless steel. This is the best quality material as it is strong, durable, holds an edge, and will last many hunting seasons. Stainless steel is also one of the easier materials to care for to ensure that they stay in good condition for a long time.

Quick Take | Best Crossbow Broadheads

Just looking for the top three best crossbow broadheads? Here they are:

  1. Wasp Archery Sharpshooter Traditional 150 Grain
  2. Maifield Archery 100 Grain
  3. Sinbadteck Hunting Broadheads

Review of the Best Crossbow Broadheads

Now that you have read about what you should consider when buying and what to expect from a great quality broadhead, it is time to look at some of the best models on the market.

Wasp Archery Sharpshooter Traditional 150 Grain Cut On Contact Broadhead

PROS

  • 1” Cutting Diameter to Ensure Large Wound Channel
  • Made From Solid Steel Ferrules for Strength and Durability
  • Self-Aligning Blade Lock System to Ensure Consistent Flight

CONS

  • 4 Blades Could Catch More Wind Than Wanted

These are sturdy, reliable, and will last you a very long time. This is a four-blade, fixed-style, 150-grain broadhead, so it will pack a punch behind each shot. Made to last with solid steel ferrules, its blades are honed to perfection at 0.040” thick main and 0.027” replaceable blades, as well.

These sharp blades allow for easy penetration of thick, tough tides without being damaged so that they will last for many seasons. The four blades ensure for a large wound channel and the weight makes sure it will fly steadily over longer distances.

Bottom Line

The Wasp Archery Sharpshooter Traditional 150-Grain are an excellent choice for beginners and experts alike. Built from solid steel ferrules, these fixed broadheads have the best of both strength and durability due to the material, making sure they will last many seasons. These models have a self-aligning blade lock system to ensure flight will be consistent shot after shot. With a cutting diameter of one-inch wide, it is sure to provide a humane ending to the animal.

However, the downside to this type is that while its four blades ensure heavy damage and a wide wound channel, they also provide more surface area to catch wind and can be thrown off target. Although this fault it is hardly unexpected and is a small one compared with the overall great quality these provide.

Maifield Archery Broadheads 100 Grain Bowhunting Arrow Head 3 Fixed Blades 6 Pack for Small Game Crossbows and Compound Bow Arrows

PROS

  • Triangle Blades Enhance Flight Stability
  • Comes With Carrying Case to Ensure Safety
  • Extremely Sharp Blades From Stainless Steel/Aluminum Mix

CONS

  • Lighter Grain Could Lessen Penetration.

The Maifield Broadhead is a fixed-style that has three blades in a triangle formation and a chisel point tip. This is one of the lighter models at only 100-grain, flies fast, and is excellent for the smaller end of the game scale. The 0.028” blades are honed to a high degree and have a 1 and 1/8” cutting diameter to open up a wide wound channel to ensure a quick, humane death.

The tip of these are very sharp as well to ensure there is quick penetration through the hide without losing too much energy before entering the animal.

The Maifield Archery Broadheads 100-Grain is a great choice for someone looking for a precision three-blade, fixed broadhead that is perfect for taking down smaller game. This one has three extremely sharp blades made from a stainless steel aluminum mix that is both strong and durable.

The blades are in a triangle shape which helps to enhance the flight stability of the model. These also come with a high quality carrying case to keep them safe while transporting and storing them. A possible downside to this type is that being only 100-grain means they are lighter and pack less of a punch behind them. This means there could be less penetration which leads to a slower, less humane death for the animal.

Bottom Line 

Overall, these are excellent quality and can still get the job done just as well as a heavier option if used with the right bow and on the right prey.

Best for the Money:
Sinbadteck Hunting Broadheads

Sinbadteck Hunting Broadheads,Sinbad Teck 12PK 3 Blades Archery Broadheads 100 Grain Screw-in Arrow Heads Arrow Tips Compatible with Crossbow and Compound Bow (Gold)

PROS

  • Three Sharp Blade Triangle Design
  • Anodized Aluminum Shaft and Stainless-Steel Blades
  • Screw-In Compatible With Crossbows and Compound Bows

CONS

  • Lighter Grain Can Lessen Penetration

The Sinbadteck Hunting Broadheads are fixed-style, equipped with three, super-sharp blades. These are 2.8” in length and are 1.035” wide. The three blade triangle makes for a more stable flight trajectory as well as helps with precision. The blades are strong and stay sharp for a decent amount of time.

While these models work the best on smaller game because of the lighter grain, they are excellent quality and with the right bow and skills can still be used to take down bigger game as well. With the three blades, there is also less surface for wind to catch on, making them more accurate than the four bladed styles.

These are great quality fixed-style with a three blade triangle design that is very sharp and lethal. Made with an anodized aluminum shaft and stainless-steel blades, they are very durable and strong to keep them in working shape for many seasons. Built to have easy installation, this model is screw-in compatible with both crossbows and compound bows.

Bottom Line

Although they are very sharp and made to last, these are on the lighter side coming in with a 100-grain weight. While this is not always a disadvantage, it can lessen the hide penetration and diminish the force at which the arrow hits its target. Overall these are an excellent choice of a fixed-style option and are perfect for game that is on the smaller end of the scale. These will last a long time and still be in excellent condition if properly cared for.

Barnett Cross Gamecrusher Broadheads 100 Grain 3 Pack

PROS

  • Super Sharp Diamize Blades
  • Offset Blades for Large Wound Channel
  • Trophy Tip Can Withstand Hitting Bone Repeatedly

CONS

  • Mechanisms Can Be Unreliable

The Barnett Cross Gamecrushers are a mechanical-style, three-blade design. The blades expand out of the body once impacting the target, creating a large wound to allow for a quick, humane death. The fact that the blades are stored in the body during flight decreases surface area for wind to catch on, making them more precise and less likely to be blown off course by a crosswind.

This type is 100-grain, putting them on the lighter end of the scale, although this does not detract from the cutting diameter they provide with the expanding blades.

The Barnett Cross Gamecrushers are a great option for someone looking to get into using mechanical broadheads, especially on smaller game, due to the lighter grain weight. The Diamize blades are honed to be extremely sharp and stay that way with proper care. They are also offset in order to create a large wound channel to ensure a quick, humane death from rapid blood loss.

Bottom Line

The trophy tip is extremely strong and durable to ensure it remains intact and in good condition even if it hits bone multiple times. The main downfall of any mechanical style is the mechanisms that hold the blades in place until impact can be damaged or fire too early if there is enough pressure exerted on them from the force of being shot.

This issue is, however, universal with mechanical options and if you are prepared to handle them, it is not a huge disadvantage. Overall, these are great quality and will get the job done for you.

Rage Bowhunting CrossbowX Mechanical Broadhead, 2 Blade 2 Inch Cutting Diameter, 100 or 125 Grain, 3 Pack

PROS

  • 2” Wide Cutting Diameter
  • Available in Both 100 and 125-Grain
  • The Ferrule Alignment System Helps With Aerodynamic Flight

CONS

  • Shock Collar Technology is Delicate and Doesn’t Always Retain the Blades Until Impact

Looking to use the best mechanical broadheads? Then look no further than the Rage Bowhunting CrossbowX. Made from durable, strong stainless-steel with a massive leading-edge blade, these are made to be effective and impressive.

Built to have excellent accuracy and a huge wound channel, they also come with a practice head so you can ensure that once you are in the field you won’t be taking a wasted shot.

The Rage Bowhunting CrossbowX is an excellent choice for someone looking to use mechanical broadheads that are extremely effective and of great quality. Built to have a huge two-inch wide cutting diameter, these provide game with a quick and humane death due to massive, rapid blood loss. These are available in both 100-grain and 125-grain to give a variety to the force they can exert and for the specific type of game you plan on hunting.

Along with the weight choices, this type is built with the ferrule alignment system in order to provide the most aerodynamic, stable flight trajectory possible. A downside is that the Shock Collar Technology that is supposed to ensure proper blade retention doesn’t always work and can mess up your shots and the overall impact these have.

Bottom Line

Overall, however, the Rage Bowhunting CrossbowX is a great choice if you are looking to take down a variety of game with accuracy and speed.

Excalibur Boltcutter 150 Grain 3-Blade Broadhead (Pack of 3)

PROS

  • Come Preassembled
  • Compatible With High Speed Crossbows
  • Heavy, Small Design Helps Improve Aerodynamics

CONS

  • Leaves Small Blood Trail

Looking to take out turkeys efficiently? Then these are for you. The Excalibur Boltcutter 150 Grain 3-Blade is a fixed-style that has the triangle design with its three blades. This type has a 1 and 1/16” cutting diameter and a chisel point tip built to withstand heavy hits to shoulders and bones alike.

With blades made from stainless-steel, these models are both durable and strong, and with proper care will last many seasons in peak condition. The three-blade, fixed design and 150-grain performance ensure you will get deep penetration on any shot, easily piercing tough hides and pushing through feathers.

Bottom Line

The Excalibur Boltcutter 150-Grain 3-Blade is one of the best fixed-style for many reasons. Coming preassembled, these models are heavy and small, allowing for speed and increased accuracy as there is less surface area for wind to catch on. Another great benefit is they are compatible with high speed crossbows, so you can hit your target quickly and have deep penetration thanks the weight and speed.

The main downside is that because these are so heavy and small as well,  they can shoot through your prey, only leaving a small opening and little to no blood trail to follow if you don’t hit anything vital on the first shot. Overall the Excalibur Boltcutter is a great type that is extremely powerful and durable and will be a quality tool for many seasons.

Muzzy Bowhunting Trocar Crossbow Broadheads 3 Blade, 1-3/16  Inch Cutting Diameter, 3 Pack

PROS

  • Sharp Contact Cut Tip
  • Short Length to Keep Shots Accurate
  • Helix-Blade Design for Extra Aerodynamics

CONS

  • Changing Blades Can Be Difficult

The Muzzy Bowhunting Trocars are three-bladed, fixed-style broadheads. Made from solid steel ferrules and sharpened to have a keen razor edge, these models are effective and lethal. They have a 1 and 3/16” cutting diameter to leave an effective wound channel and 0.035” thick razor sharp steel blades that are strong and durable.

These types will be able to penetrate anything, even with the lighter grain weight and are also strong enough to withstand hitting bone and not being damaged. This means you can use them for many hunting seasons so long as they are kept sharp.

The Muzzy Bowhunting Trocars are excellent, quality, fixed broadheads built to last and help you keep up your accuracy and precision even over a distance. The short length of the model helps keep your shots accurate and reduces the amount of surface area for wind to catch on and disrupt the flight path. The Helix blade design is an added feature to provide extra aerodynamics to ensure you can take the most accurate shots possible from where you are.

Bottom Line

These are also contact cut tips, which are extremely sharp and tear through anything on contact, making them extremely effective at getting through thick hides. The main downside to these types is that even with the proper tools, changing the blades can be difficult.

However, this is not such a bad thing as they are very durable and the blades shouldn’t have to be changed often. Overall the Muzzy Bowhunting Trocar Broadheads are a great option for anyone looking for 100-grain fixed-style.

Rage Bowhunting Hypodermic Crossbow Mechanical Broadhead, 2 Blade 2 Inch Cutting Diameter 100 or 125 Grain, 3 Pack

PROS

  • 2” Cutting Diameter
  • Hybrid Tip Provides Surgical Accuracy
  • Shock Collar Technology to Retain Blades

CONS

  • Expanding Mechanisms Can Fail

The Rage Bowhunting Hypodermic Mechanical Broadheads are a powerful, expanding option that will get the job done quickly. Made to last from strong stainless-steel and including a large leading-edge blade, 0.035” thick razor-sharp blades, a two-inch cutting diameter, and available in both 100-grain and 125-grain, these models have it all to provide you with the power and precision to take down your prey.

Like many other Rage broadheads, these hypodermic models are equipped with the ferrule alignment system to promote an aerodynamic flight path. To assist with the accuracy of your shots, the Rage Hypodermic also comes with a practice head so you don’t have to worry about damaging the field ones in practice.

Bottom Line

These are great-quality, mechanical option that have an impressive, large two-inch cutting diameter to ensure a quick and humane death. The hybrid tip is super sharp, provides surgical accuracy, and cuts through anything. Along with having the ferrule alignment technology, these have improved Shock Collar Technology to ensure proper blade retention until the arrow hits its target.

Unfortunately, the main failing of this type is the same as in any other mechanical broadheads and that is, the expanding mechanisms can be damaged and either fail to fire or release too early. However, with proper care and handling, these problems can be minimized, making them not worth the worry when you compare the benefits to its downsides.

Overall, these are some of the best on the market, especially from Rage and should be considered a great option.

Types of Broadheads

Now that you have looked at some of the top models on today’s market, you will have noticed some variations in form and exactly how they take down the game they are after. There are three main types:

  • Mechanical Broadheads

Mechanical broadheads-the name pretty much says it all. These are basically small machines. The blades stay tucked into the body during flight and then release upon impact with the target, expanding the wound channel and inflicting greater damage. A perk of these is that they have increased accuracy because the blades stay tucked, reducing the amount of wind that is caught.

  • Fixed Broadheads

Fixed broadheads have blades that stay exactly where they are all the time. Normally, these are a little bit heavier duty and have stronger blades. They are fairly accurate, but where these really shine is with their reliability and the fact that they penetrate deeper than mechanical broadheads do.

  • Hybrid Broadheads

Hybrid broadheads are a cross between fixed and mechanical with both fixed and expanding blades to increase both the reliability and the width of the wound channel they cause.

Conclusion

Now that you have seen some of the best options of broadheads on the market, both mechanical and fixed-style, looked at what aspects you should consider before buying, and what you should expect to get out of great quality, it is time for you to go and see what type is best for your style of hunting and the game you are after. 

Leave a Comment